November 11, 2026

Return to the full correspondence index

Sent · 6:14 pm Vancouver time

FIPPA request — OAG Busters complaint assessment and underlying evidence, September 28–November 11, 2026

From  Great Scott Gilbert <greatscottgilbert@gmail.com>

To  foi@vancouver.ca

Date in the email  Wed, 11 Nov 2026 19:14:34 -0600

Dear City of Vancouver Access to Information and Privacy Office, **Formal request under section 5 of the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act (FIPPA)** Applicant: Scott Gilbert Response and delivery email: greatscottgilbert@gmail.com Telephone: [phone number omitted] Please provide the existing records described below concerning the Office of the Auditor General's (OAG) assessment of my complaint about Busters Towing / All Tech Transport Ltd., vehicle-weight classifications, towing charges and City contract oversight. This request specifically concerns the evidence obtained, enquiries made and decisions communicated by the OAG, rather than a new general search of all Busters transactions. Relevant correspondence includes: - My September 28, 2026 audit request, sent from [email address omitted]; - The October 23, 2026 response signed “Anna” on behalf of the OAG, referring to a telephone enquiry to the City Impound Yard and a formal weight-dispute/refund mechanism; - The October 30, 2026 correspondence from the Whistleblowing mailbox about further enquiries; and - The November 10, 2026 response signed by Varun Banthia, Senior Auditor (Whistleblowing), stating that Engineering Services supplied a list of recent misclassifications and explanations, that errors appeared rare, and that further whistleblower investigation would not proceed. That response also distinguished possible future performance-audit consideration. The subject line of the November 10 thread begins “Updated Busters audit request”. Any tow counts appearing in earlier correspondence are matters for reconciliation against the original records, not verified findings asserted by this access request. **Date range and limits** Search for records created, received, circulated or used in this assessment from September 28 through November 11, 2026, inclusive. Include earlier-origin documents only where they were obtained, supplied, reviewed, cited or relied upon in that assessment, and the applicable assessment/process guidance specified below. I am not requesting a search of every historical towing transaction. This request is distinct from my November 5, 2026 request concerning City payments, towing volumes, site rents and broader audit controls, and from related file 2026-655. Please avoid duplicate production of identical records already disclosed, identifying the earlier disclosure and page/file reference instead. This request does not replace or withdraw those requests. **Records requested** 1. **My complaint assessment and decision file.** Intake and case notes, assessment worksheets, recorded findings, evidence inventories, internal correspondence and substantive review comments concerning my complaint; records of the reasons for declining further investigation; and approval/sign-off records identifying the decision-maker, reviewer and authority relied upon. Include any record showing whether and when Auditor General Mike Macdonell personally reviewed, approved or was advised of the assessment or closure decision. Routine duplicate copies of my own correspondence can be omitted unless they contain new annotations, forwarding comments or attachments. 2. **The questions asked and answers received.** Correspondence, attachments, questionnaires, relevant work-related messages, meeting notes, telephone notes and existing call summaries between the OAG and Engineering Services, Parking Operations/Enforcement, City Impound Yard staff, Busters/All Tech, or other contract-oversight staff concerning this assessment. This includes the enquiry described in the October 23 reply and the subsequent enquiries underlying the November 10 reply. Please include records identifying the participants, dates, information requested, responses, follow-up questions, and any requests that were declined or not answered. I am not asking for transcripts to be newly created. 3. **The actual misclassification list and its provenance.** The list, spreadsheet, report or other record supplied by City staff and referred to in the November 10 reply, with covering correspondence, attachments, relevant versions, existing source references and existing extraction criteria or saved queries. Include records identifying the period covered, how cases entered the list, and whether cases were identified through complaints, refund requests, routine checks or independent sampling, where recorded. 4. **Evidence supporting the conclusions.** Records actually supplied, examined or relied upon to conclude that misclassifications were rare, legitimate errors rather than intentional or frequent, and that City oversight was sufficient. Include existing sampling or testing records; sample-selection criteria; any review of invoices that had not generated complaints; relevant original/corrected invoices and classification/weight-source records used in that assessment; and any recorded verification of the explanations supplied. Include existing records distinguishing affected vehicles, incorrect tow transactions, complaints, refunds, and the total population or sample examined. I seek the existing basis for these conclusions, not a new statistical analysis or reconstructed error rate. 5. **The dispute procedure and oversight evidence cited.** The written vehicle-weight dispute/refund mechanism referred to in the October 23 reply, together with the versions, effective-date/approval records, customer-notice material and evidence of actual operation that were supplied or relied upon. Include oversight reports, checks, instructions, training or corrective-action records supplied or relied upon during this assessment. If the conclusion rested on an oral description rather than a written procedure, please provide the existing notes or records of that description. Include any relevant, non-privileged records considered concerning the City's ability to obtain the contractor's underlying records or exercise contractual inspection/audit rights. 6. **Separate performance-audit consideration.** Records referring my systemic billing/contract-oversight concerns to the Auditor General for audit planning; any resulting risk/priority assessment or decision recorded by November 11; and any scope/status document supplied or cited in relation to the OAG's stated plans to review enforcement of the Impoundment By-law. This is limited to consideration of my complaint and the review mentioned in the October 23 reply, not the OAG's entire audit-planning file. 7. **Applicable assessment and delegation guidance.** The version in force during this assessment of the process guide referenced in section 6.1 of Whistleblower Policy COUN-010, and any relevant written criteria or delegation/approval instructions governing preliminary assessment, closure without further investigation, referral for performance-audit consideration, or reliance on information supplied by the department whose oversight is questioned. Publicly available records may be supplied by a precise link and version/date. No personnel file is requested. **Search locations and form of access** Please coordinate searches of the relevant OAG case file and shared mailboxes (OAG@vancouver.ca and Whistleblowing@vancouver.ca), the records of Varun Banthia and the handler of the October 23 reply, and the relevant Engineering Services/Parking contract-management records and custodians identified by the enquiries. Search identifiers include Scott Gilbert, both email addresses above, Busters/Buster's, All Tech, my GMC motorhome and Grumman, and plate [plate omitted]. Please provide electronic records, retaining email dates, sender/recipient fields and attachments. Native CSV/XLSX is preferred for existing structured lists; searchable PDF is suitable for other records. I do not seek other motorists' names, contact details, licence plates or VINs. Please sever those identifiers while retaining non-identifying transaction references, dates, classes, weight information, amounts and the information needed to understand the assessment. Please do not redact my own information as third-party information. If information is withheld, please identify the applicable statutory provision and release reasonably severable portions under section 4(2). Please distinguish records not located from records withheld or considered outside City custody/control. For any not-held category, please describe the searches and relevant custodians consulted in the response, consistently with the duty to assist. The OAG By-law's sections 4.8–4.9 expressly address FIPPA and City handling of access requests; confidentiality alone should not be treated as a substitute for the applicable statutory analysis. **Fees, registration and preservation** Please process records constituting my own personal information without fees under section 75(3). Where the associated general records require separate registration, please advise and register that component without allowing a general-records fee issue to delay the independently processable personal-information component. I am not asserting that every underlying operational record is personal information merely because it was considered in my case. Please advise whether the $10 general-request application fee is required and provide the official payment link or payment instructions. No payment is enclosed. I request a waiver of any additional search/processing fees under section 75(5)(b), because these records concern the reliability of independent oversight of a City contractor and potential effects on other vehicle owners, beyond my individual refund dispute. This is not a claim that section 75(5) waives the application fee. If a service-fee estimate is necessary, provide it by category and allow narrowing or staged disclosure before chargeable work proceeds. I do not authorize unquoted additional charges. Please preserve responsive records and associated attachments, versions and case notes while this request and any related access review remain outstanding. Please acknowledge receipt, assign the appropriate file number(s), and confirm the applicable response deadline and any outstanding registration/payment requirement. Please communicate and deliver records to greatscottgilbert@gmail.com rather than relying on postal delivery or my older domain email address. Sincerely, Scott Gilbert

Link to this email

Sent · 2:42 pm Vancouver time

Busters protest

From  Great Scott Gilbert <greatscottgilbert@gmail.com>

To  Justin Schrump <justin.schrump@busterstowing.com>, Jim Dent <Jim.Dent@busterstowing.com>, David.Cheung2@vancouver.ca

Date in the email  Wed, 11 Nov 2026 14:42:31 -0700

Hey guys, I showed up today for a protest your office but only realized once I arrived that today was remembrance day so will return tomorrow instead. I have a large powered speaker that I plan to use to play the attached songs that an AI helped me write and produce that I will be playing and distributing along with a double sided 8.5x11 flyer that covers the case I'm making for a full public inquiry, possible replacement of the city auditor if the records don't get disclosed and internal records audited and to be clear I think this issue is significant enough that it will make me mayor in 2030 Give the attached songs a quick listen cause they will be played round the clock on a loud speaker starting tomorrow morning. I'm still open to a conversation about resolution without a big public campaign but you have not demonstrated much interest in that so I will proceed as described and exercise my right to hold peaceful protests of what I think the voters of Vancouver will agree is more than improper. Please make sure the speaker is safe I'll return this evening or first thing tomorrow but could not carry it since I no longer have a vehicle and it's needed for the planned protest events. VPD has been notified and I will not obstruct your entryway and will remain outside as much as possible just playing the attached tunes and handing out campaign materials calling for a public inquiry and full audit plus every penny repaid to every person for all charges that are not expressly authorized in publicly available material and described on the city website - a standard above what you have refunded so far but one that is more than reasonable. Scott
Attachment filenames (3)
  • Gimme That Loot (2).mp3
  • Ridin' Dirty II.mp3
  • City Hall — The First Test (1).mp3

Link to this email