Sent · 2:32 pm Vancouver time
FOI 2026-655 — wrong vehicle records and outstanding supplemental search
Dear Access to Information and Privacy Division,
I am following up on my September 26 request for a supplemental search in City FOI 2026-655. I have not located a substantive response.
Your September 25 letter correctly describes my two GMC motorhome tows, near Powell and Heatley on July 10, 2026 (Busters reference 786533, job 3786533), and near Main and Terminal on July 20 (job 3789702). The operational records in the package instead show the same Evo Toyota at 600 National Avenue and 100 East Pender Street, tickets GY87520 and GZ11145. My own notice about the GMC appears later in the package.
Please confirm how those ticket numbers were matched to my request and whether their inclusion was an error. If they were included in error, please let me know whether your privacy office assessed the release and whether you will issue a corrected package.
Please search the relevant City systems using GMC plate [plate omitted], both dates and locations, and the Busters references. Identify the units and systems searched and the identifiers used, including the City’s own dispatch, daily towing reports, Parking Enforcement, 311, and contract-management and claims records. Please explain whether each requested category of contractor records is under City control, including what access the operative contract provides, and identify any appropriate custodian for records the City does not hold or control.
For the full-page s. 14 redaction (PDF page 12) and the redaction at the top of PDF page 13, please identify the record type and date where possible and confirm whether any reasonably severable portion can be released.
Please acknowledge receipt and reply to this address.
Scott Gilbert
greatscottgilbert@gmail.com
Link to this email
Delivery notice · 8:34 am Vancouver time
Delivery Status Notification (Failure)
** Message blocked **
Your message to [email address omitted] has been blocked. See technical details below for more information.
Learn more here:
https://aka.ms/EXOSmtpErrors
(Warning: This link will take you to a third-party site)
The response from the remote server was:
550 5.4.1 Recipient address rejected: Access denied. For more information see
https://aka.ms/EXOSmtpErrors [YT2PEPF000001CF.CANPRD01.PROD.OUTLOOK.COM 2026-11-12T15:34:56.206Z 08DF401FF1DC95CE]
Attachment filenames (2)
- icon.png
- warning_triangle.png
Link to this email
Delivery notice · 8:27 am Vancouver time
Delivery Status Notification (Failure)
** Address not found **
Your message wasn't delivered to [email address omitted] because the address couldn't be found, or is unable to receive mail.
Learn more here:
https://support.google.com/mail/?p=NoSuchUser
The response was:
550 5.1.1 The email account that you tried to reach does not exist. Please try double-checking the recipient's email address for typos or unnecessary spaces. For more information, go to
https://support.google.com/mail/?p=NoSuchUser af79cd13be357-94932ddf103sor257662985a.4 - gsmtp
Attachment filenames (1)
Link to this email
Delivery notice · 8:27 am Vancouver time
Delivery Status Notification (Failure)
** Address not found **
Your message wasn't delivered to mayor@vancouver.ca because the address couldn't be found, or is unable to receive mail.
The response from the remote server was:
550 5.1.1 User Unknown
Attachment filenames (1)
Link to this email
Delivery notice · 8:27 am Vancouver time
Delivery Status Notification (Failure)
** Message too large **
Your message couldn't be delivered to [email address omitted] because it exceeds the size limit. Try reducing the message size and resending.
The response from the remote server was:
552 5.2.3 message size exceeds fixed maximum message size
Attachment filenames (1)
Link to this email
Sent · 8:27 am Vancouver time
Re: Notice of Peaceful Demonstrations — November 6–7, 2026
This is possibly the biggest case of corruption and coverup in recent
Vancouver history.
Busters towing is running a racket and charging often up to 4 times what
the city website says is the maximum allowed for a certain tow by
misclassifying tow weight, calling things police impound that do not
qualify as one and holding vehicles extra days without any basis, adding
load and secure charges when no such work was done and without any
documentation and additional time when none was taken then billing 2 fuel
surcharges. This is criminal and it appears VPD is blocking any request to
investigate while city auditor does the same.
See attached image showing the difference between cat 2 van vs class 3
commercial vehicle and class 1 sedan... can you not easily spot the
difference between these and with some practice? If not, the weight class
is printed on the door tags, and can be looked up using either the vin or
the make/model/year - both of which are recorded so they can identify your
vehicle when you call in. Busters has a fleet of experienced tow drivers
and has been in business even longer than the 28 years they have held the
city tow contract. After much effort to muddy the waters by first saying
the weight was listed on the invoice from the driver and that person is not
here now and we cannot let you speak to them to later saying they require
photos of the door tags to determine the weight class, then saying they
thought lbs was kg in the numbers on the tags, to finally saying sometimes
people make mistakes. But it's all bullshit because upon closer
examination *every
single tow out of a sample of 13, that spans multiple years, multiple
vehicles and many tow drivers, every single invoice was incorrectly
classified and always had the effect of dramatically increasing the invoice
total. Buster has acknowledged that this did happen in all of the 13 tows*
and despite many statements and signs on the receipts and invoices and
plaques in the office that all say clearly NO REFUNDS and tow charges are
non-negotiable, they did reluctantly issue me $719 refund for 5 of the tows
from my most recent vehicle, several months after I began to complain about
this, and notably only after the election. When I provided the vin and ICBC
papers for a different vehicle that I had to sell for a fraction of its
value to limit the daily storage fees, busters staff confirmed by looking
at the same papers that are used to release the vehicle that it was a class
2 weight, and then confirmed that every one of the 8 tows they had records
for on their screen was billed as a class 3 tow resulting in charges of
over 100 dollars per tow on average that should never have been charged. I
asked why then was I charged when you have everything you need to know the
correct invoice amount and the woman at the cash register simply said she
did not know but I could speak to Justin about it. Almost every time I call
Justin I get voicemail and he is never in the office, and he simply does
not respond to most questions by email and when he calls me it's from a
private number with several clicks and a long pause before his voice comes
on indicating the call is being recorded despite an absence of any
disclosure of that happening. This suggests he is worried about the fact I
am asking for a refund and is already lawyering up. Despite many months of
asking simple questions like who records the vehicle weight and how is it
determined, nobody at either busters or the city will answer that question.
So I built an app on my phone using ChatGPT where I simply said to it:
build me an app that allows me to input the vin or make/model/year of a
vehicle and give me the weight class of that vehicle in response and it
made the app in under 5 minutes. That app is now available for anyone to
use and is available at bustersclassaction.ca and because 100 percent of
the 13 tow sample I have was overcharged, I asked the city in a foi request
to disclose the make/model/year of every tow they have records for and the
corresponding invoice amount. Despite the busters contract with the city
clearly saying that this information must be recorded by busters and
provided to the city, my request was denied saying they do not have care
and control of this information. That is bullshit and you can ask any AI to
find the reference in the contract which is available on the city website.
So I referred this matter to the VPD and asked them to investigate senior
management and determine if there is evidence that they may be doing this
by design particularly since weight class is just one of four tactics used
to drive the invoice amount higher all of which are outside of what is
described on the city website and city tow bylaw. VPD major crimes
investigator David Silverstein declined saying he could not open an
investigation based on a report by email despite me having his email
address because he opened an arson investigation previously that I had
reported by email. He said I had to call non emergency and when I did the
call taker put me on hold after I explained the situation and returned
after speaking to a supervisor to tell me that this was a civil matter and
not their jurisdiction. I asked for a file number to document that I had
made this report and requested an investigation and for the only time in
over a decade of making numerous reports on a range of matters, this is the
only time that I was denied a file number and no reason was provided. They
simply said the call was being recorded and that's all they could tell me.
So I brought this to the city auditor who first declined saying she was
satisfied with the response that busters provided in a statement where they
claimed to have a tow weight dispute process. I have never been told
anything like that from anyone at busters despite many complaints and
requests. The auditor also could not explain the process or provide a
reference to any place that describes it. We must ask, Why would you need
to have a dispute process if the matter can be resolved by looking up the
vin or make/model/year and both records are associated with every tow? So I
submitted a request for reconsideration and again was declined this time
saying they looked into the matter and were satisfied that this discrepancy
is rare and incidents are isolated.
But there should never be any discrepancy if the value can reliably
determined by at least 3 different mechanisms available to the company, and
the company has acknowledged under pressure that every single one of the 13
tow sample has been overcharged.
How can a city auditor make such a statement in the face of this sample
that covers multiple vehicles, multiple years and many different drivers as
well as review of the invoices by senior management at a company with
decades of experience for something you don't even need the vin for because
you can clearly see the difference and any elementary school student could
reliably sort a series of photos of vehicles. This is not isolated to me or
just a few tows it happens on every single one and tows that the city
website says should be 140 bucks are invoiced at 560 and nobody but me
raises a stink about it. This practice has cost me so many vehicles to be
lost to the city impound yard over the past decade, many of which have been
my home and each time busters got to sell the vehicle I had paid money for
because I could not afford tow invoices that were inflated as high as 3.5
times what the maximum rate the city website says they can charge. Even
after they admit to overcharging me they now refuse to provide even the
dates and totals I paid for the first 8 in my samples that I saw briefly on
their screen and the details were described by staff but now they are
refusing to give me any more information and not returning my calls asking
for the same refund I already received for the same practice on the first 5
tows. Only a willfully blind person could conclude that this is an innocent
mistake, a rare occurrence and something that does not meet the threshold
for an audit or criminal investigation and the fact that both the VPD and
city auditor have taken this position is why I am declaring this to be a
large scale fraud and corruption racket that amounts to an organized crime
operation and the very people within the city who are paid very well to
root this type of thing out appear to in fact be complicit in it and
actively covering it up. If there is any evidence that this is not the case
I would love to see it but until that is demonstrated I am going to call it
what it looks like and put the onus on those who are paid to investigate
these matters to produce the records proving it is not to clear their
names. I am now homeless because of this malicious practice where wealthy
and powerful people in this city pay huge sums of money to police and city
political efforts so they have a free pass to prey on me and hundreds of
thousands of other people in this city and I cannot believe that I am the
only person who notices that this is happening and is demanding that it
end. Anyone who has actively participated in this and has known or ought to
have known or had a duty to investigate it and good reason to and decided
not to needs to be fired and many of them need to be charged and sent to
prison. I am not going to tone down that rhetoric and if anyone has a
problem with me saying that then debate me on CBC News as to why because
you are either a crook or a coward and I am neither so fuck you pay me back
the money because busters staff have acknowledged that they overcharged
every single tow and it has taken my home more than once and these assholes
need to stop this and the city and cops need to do their friggin jobs
because I'm not paid and am doing this with a damn cell phone while
standing in the rain.
I plan to file a private prosecution in court at 9am because VPD seem to be
conflicted on this because they share the busters tow yard for police
impounds and receive some of the money going through there. In the 90 min
before I file 4 drones have passed over me as I sit in a plastic cart at
the end of industrial ave and I can only suspect they are VPD drones trying
to locate me before I make it to the court house to file charges that
implicate VPD and city auditor in a corruption scandal like none in recent
history.
Video of drones in past 20 min
https://youtube.com/shorts/gAwRFnaa9xI?si=4savnisFmSJT2u4O
Scope: the evidence available suggests $120 or more has been overcharged on
average for every tow (13/13) with 50,000 or more tows per year and 28
years of this I mean the extent of this is potentially tens to hundreds of
millions of dollars. If they claim otherwise then show the records but
that's what the evidence available to me suggests and my efforts to get the
data that would show the scale have been blocked without good reason . Why?
This smells like a very bad case.
Protest signs and songs are attached. Loudspeaker was left at busters
yesterday but has since gone missing so I assume staff took it to prevent
me from protesting this. VPD should ask where it is and check video it's a
$1200 speaker and I emailed busters explaining I am on foot now cause I
lost my rv as a result of them taking every penny I have and didn't want to
protest on remembrance day but plan to today so left the speaker there
since I cannot lug it around all day and now it's gone and staff say they
don't know where it went. Honestly if you see what ChatGPT is saying about
the response from the city auditor in attached screenshots it does not look
good for the trust the public will have in either auditor or law
enforcement if I have to investigate and bring charges on this all by
myself with no money and no support while sleeping outside I mean this is
insane.
Pls listen to the three signs that an AI wrote about this and my campaign I
think they are hilarious! Music video to be released in a few days
featuring me with purple dreds and gold teeth - Great Scott album called
Busters Rhymes. Hahahaha come on we have to laugh a bit in all this and
these clowns deserve it so share the music in sure it will go viral.
Thanks y'all for reading this far
Scott Gilbert
Attachment filenames (18)
- 1823.png
- 1679.png
- 1676.png
- 1677.png
- 1806.jpg
- 1674.png
- 1673.png
- 1678.png
- 1804.jpg
- 1675.png
- 1803.jpg
- 1680.png
- 1672.png
- Gimme_That_Loot.mp3
- Ridin_Dirty_II.mp3
- City_Hall_The_First_Test.mp3
- 1573.png
- 1570.png
Link to this email
Sent · 7:27 am Vancouver time
For Mayor and Council — drone sightings and request for clarification
Dear Mayor Fry and members of Vancouver City Council,
City Clerk, please circulate this to the Mayor and all councillors.
This morning I observed what appeared to be four drones flying overhead within about ten minutes. Here is my video:
https://youtube.com/shorts/gAwRFnaa9xI?si=4savnisFmSJT2u4O
The timing concerned me because I planned to go to Vancouver Provincial Court at 9 a.m. regarding a private Information about Busters Towing. I have also raised questions about the VPD response and the Auditor General’s review. I am concerned about possible interference with my access to court. I could not identify the operators or determine why the drones were there.
Please advise how I can request confirmation of whether VPD or another City agency operated drones in the area at the time, and how I can report my concern for independent review. I can provide the approximate time and location privately if needed.
Scott Gilbert
Link to this email
Sent · 2:23 am Vancouver time
Re: URGENT: Busters towing charges, request for independent review, and personal safety concerns
City Clerk, please circulate this follow-up to Mayor Pete Fry and all members of Vancouver City Council.
I’m following up on my statement about Busters Towing and the City’s oversight. At 9 a.m. today, November 12, I intend to ask the Vancouver Provincial Court criminal registry how to present a private Information if the evidence supports a specific offence. The one-page overview in the attached ZIP explains the process.
Busters confirmed that it corrected five bills from Category 3 to Category 2, a $719.23 adjustment. I still need the original and revised invoices, the weight records used to set the charges, and the authority and work records for load-and-secure, standby, fuel, storage and impound charges. The City’s towing agreement calls for visible rate posting at the appropriate facilities. I did not see a rate schedule at the office I used and would like the City to verify what was posted there.
The Auditor’s office relied on a list and explanations from Engineering Services to describe the errors as rare and declined to investigate the whistleblower complaint further. Its reply gave no sample size, time period or method for testing original bills. Given Engineering’s contract role and the Police Board’s involvement in the towing agreement, I’m asking for an independent review with published terms of reference, methods and findings. Please preserve the tow orders, dispatch and classification logs, original and amended invoices, refunds and the records used in the City’s and Auditor’s assessments. I ask for every verified overcharge to be repaid and any evidence of wrongdoing to be referred to the appropriate authorities.
I plan to demonstrate peacefully today outside City Hall and Busters Towing, keeping entrances, sidewalks and traffic clear. VPD’s protest liaison indicated on November 5 that it foresaw no issues with the earlier plan as described and asked for an update on November 10. I am concerned about retaliation after being told someone associated with Busters might be following me. That report is secondhand. I ask VPD to identify a contact and provide a reference number for reporting any specific incidents.
The ZIP also includes my signs, flyer and screenshots of the outstanding questions. Some signs give my working estimates of the disputed tows. The hip-hop tracks are AI-generated protest commentary based on the correspondence.
Scott Gilbert
greatscottgilbert@gmail.com
Earlier correspondence included in the email
On Thu, 12 Nov 2026 00:56:52 -0800, Great Scott Gilbert <greatscottgilbert@gmail.com> wrote:
PERSONAL STATEMENT — November 12, 2026
Subject: Busters towing charges, unanswered questions, and my concerns about accountability and personal safety
I am writing to document my experience investigating what I believe may be a systematic pattern of overcharging by Busters Towing, and what I regard as repeated institutional failures to investigate it. These are my observations, allegations, inferences, and fears; I am not presenting suspicions of corruption, kickbacks, or planned retaliation as established facts.
• HOW THE CHARGES BECOME DIFFICULT TO CHALLENGE
In my experience, the applicable rate schedule has not been posted at the Busters office, although I understand the contract to require it. Customers see a weight class on their invoice without a meaningful explanation of how it was determined. When I challenged it, I was told that the driver recorded the class, that Busters received and paid the subcontractor’s invoice, and therefore that the customer must pay too. I was not given the driver’s name or contact information.
Counter staff could not explain the method and referred my questions to Justin, who was not on site and was often unavailable. Questions remained unanswered. Each individual disputed tow can involve approximately $120, an amount too small for many people to spend weeks pursuing through correspondence or legal proceedings.
Most people rarely have a vehicle towed and do not know its gross vehicle weight rating (GVWR). Weight ratings may be listed in pounds on a vehicle tag while tow categories use kilograms. The similar acronyms and unit conversions create genuine confusion for ordinary drivers. But professional towing operators have every reason to understand and verify these distinctions. I fear the system takes advantage of that imbalance in knowledge, with plausible explanations and referrals that exhaust complainants.
• WHAT MY OWN RECORDS SHOW
Busters refunded me $719.23 following corrections relating to five tows. That is an average of $143.85 per tow across those five transactions. This is a refund of actual charges, not an estimate of what every tow costs.
I have located records relating to 13 tows involving different vehicles, drivers, and years. My review indicates an overcharge on every one of those 13. Eight remain unresolved to my satisfaction. My interpretation of those records needs independent examination; it does not establish that all customers have been overcharged.
I also question extra items such as load-and-secure, standby, fuel surcharges and impound-related charges. Those represent potentially separate mechanisms, each requiring review against the applicable contract and rate schedule.
• THE COMPLAINT AND RECORDS MAZE
When I questioned these issues, I encountered a succession of referrals and barriers rather than a clear, documented explanation. The City Auditor’s office referred to a weight-class dispute process, but I have not been provided a usable account of that process or its results. I question why there should be substantial disputes over vehicle classification in cases where the VIN, make, model, year, and manufacturer’s weight label should permit verification.
The towing contract appears to contemplate detailed records, including GPS information and tow documentation. Yet FOI responses have, in my understanding, denied that the City has custody or control of certain records. My attempts to request a VPD investigation were redirected, and I was unable to obtain even the occurrence or reference number I requested to document the complaint.
The Auditor’s office subsequently said it was satisfied such problems were rare. I do not know what underlying records or sampling supported that conclusion, particularly given the 13 tow records I had supplied. I believe a genuinely independent audit must explain its methodology, obtain original tow and billing records, inspect the classifications and refunds, and distinguish isolated mistakes from recurring practices.
• WHY THE POTENTIAL SCALE WARRANTS INDEPENDENT INVESTIGATION
For illustration only, if a company handled 50,000 relevant tows per year over 28 years, and if every one involved $100 in excess charges, the arithmetic would be $140 million (50,000 × 28 × $100). The volume, time span, prevalence and average excess amount in that example are NOT established by my sample, and this is NOT a proven loss figure. It demonstrates why accurate historical tow counts and a representative independent invoice audit matter. If other charging mechanisms also produce excess fees, the exposure could differ significantly.
I suspect the combination of opaque invoices, inaccessible records, delayed explanations, partial refunds and institutional reluctance to scrutinize the matter may be protecting more than accidental errors. I worry about possible collusion, kickbacks and entrenched financial interests, but I have no direct evidence establishing a kickback scheme or the complicity of named officials. Those are questions for independent investigators, not conclusions I can responsibly certify.
• MY FEAR OF RETALIATION AND MY REQUEST TO THE MEDIA
My campaigning and public protest have been unusually visible, including taking my RV to City Hall, painting large protest lettering on it, and calling for a full accounting. I was a mayoral candidate in 2026 and intend to continue raising this issue, including in the lead-up to 2030.
I am increasingly afraid that continued scrutiny could lead to retaliation, including an arrest, detention, injury, or even violence against me. I fear something may happen within the next two weeks. This is my prediction and fear, not evidence that anyone has planned to harm me, and I cannot identify a person who has made such a plan. I want my concern documented openly in advance, not treated as proof of a conspiracy.
I ask CBC, the Vancouver Sun, CityNews, the Mayor, Council and the appropriate independent oversight bodies to review the invoices, corrected classifications, refunds, contract, complaint correspondence and records-access responses now. Please ask Busters, City staff, the Auditor and VPD for their accounts; verify the figures independently; preserve relevant records; and insist on a transparent, methodologically credible audit.
I want public accountability, accurate refunds for any proven overcharges, and a safe way to continue lawful criticism and protest.
Scott Gilbert
greatscottgilbert@gmail.com
Attachment filenames (1)
- Busters_Follow_Up_Attachments_2026-11-12.zip
Link to this email
Automated notice · 1:57 am Vancouver time
Automatic reply: URGENT: Busters towing charges, request for independent review, and personal safety concerns
Thank you for contacting the City Clerk’s Office. This is an automatic reply to let you know that we have received your email.
If you are writing to Mayor and Council, please use the following options instead:
* Rezoning Applications: Each rezoning application has its own web page that can be found on the City’s Shape Your City website. To submit your comments regarding a rezoning application, please fill out the project’s online feedback form, which can be found on the Shape Your City website here<
https://www.shapeyourcity.ca/rezoning>.
* Public Hearings: All Public Hearing correspondence must be placed on the public record. Your name will be made public; however, your contact information will not be posted online. To submit your comments for a Public Hearing item, you can complete the online web form here<
https://vancouver.ca/your-government/contact-council-public-hearing.aspx>.
* Urgent Concerns: Phone 3-1-1 or [phone number omitted] if you are located outside Vancouver.
* General Feedback: For general comments and concerns, you can use the Mayor and Councillors’ web form here<
https://vancouver.ca/your-government/contact-council.aspx>.
* Council Meeting Agenda Items: For feedback and comments regarding Council meeting agenda items, you can use the Mayor and Councillors’ web form here<
https://vancouver.ca/your-government/contact-council.aspx>.
Link to this email
Delivery notice · 1:56 am Vancouver time
Undeliverable: URGENT: Busters towing charges, request for independent review, and personal safety concerns
Delivery has failed to these recipients or groups:
ken.sim@vancouver.ca<mailto:ken.sim@vancouver.ca>
Your message couldn't be delivered to the recipient because you don't have permission to send to it.
Ask the recipient's email admin to add you to the accept list for the recipient.
For more information, see DSN 5.7.129 Errors in Exchange Online and Office 365<
https://go.microsoft.com/fwlink/?LinkId=389365>.
Diagnostic information for administrators:
Generating server: YT6PR01MB10925.CANPRD01.PROD.OUTLOOK.COM
ken.sim@vancouver.ca
Remote server returned '550 5.7.129 RESOLVER.RST.RestrictedToRecipientsPermission; not authorized to send to recipient because the sender isn't on the recipient's list of senders to accept mail from'
[Mail-routing headers omitted.]
Link to this email
Sent · 1:56 am Vancouver time
URGENT: Busters towing charges, request for independent review, and personal safety concerns
PERSONAL STATEMENT — November 12, 2026
Subject: Busters towing charges, unanswered questions, and my concerns about accountability and personal safety
I am writing to document my experience investigating what I believe may be a systematic pattern of overcharging by Busters Towing, and what I regard as repeated institutional failures to investigate it. These are my observations, allegations, inferences, and fears; I am not presenting suspicions of corruption, kickbacks, or planned retaliation as established facts.
1. HOW THE CHARGES BECOME DIFFICULT TO CHALLENGE
In my experience, the applicable rate schedule has not been posted at the Busters office, although I understand the contract to require it. Customers see a weight class on their invoice without a meaningful explanation of how it was determined. When I challenged it, I was told that the driver recorded the class, that Busters received and paid the subcontractor's invoice, and therefore that the customer must pay too. I was not given the driver's name or contact information.
Counter staff could not explain the method and referred my questions to Justin, who was not on site and was often unavailable. Questions remained unanswered. Each individual disputed tow can involve approximately $120, an amount too small for many people to spend weeks pursuing through correspondence or legal proceedings.
Most people rarely have a vehicle towed and do not know its gross vehicle weight rating (GVWR). Weight ratings may be listed in pounds on a vehicle tag while tow categories use kilograms. The similar acronyms and unit conversions create genuine confusion for ordinary drivers. But professional towing operators have every reason to understand and verify these distinctions. I fear the system takes advantage of that imbalance in knowledge, with plausible explanations and referrals that exhaust complainants.
2. WHAT MY OWN RECORDS SHOW
Busters refunded me $719.23 following corrections relating to five tows. That is an average of $143.85 per tow across those five transactions. This is a refund of actual charges, not an estimate of what every tow costs.
I have located records relating to 13 tows involving different vehicles, drivers, and years. My review indicates an overcharge on every one of those 13. Eight remain unresolved to my satisfaction. My interpretation of those records needs independent examination; it does not establish that all customers have been overcharged.
I also question extra items such as load-and-secure, standby, fuel surcharges and impound-related charges. Those represent potentially separate mechanisms, each requiring review against the applicable contract and rate schedule.
3. THE COMPLAINT AND RECORDS MAZE
When I questioned these issues, I encountered a succession of referrals and barriers rather than a clear, documented explanation. The City Auditor's office referred to a weight-class dispute process, but I have not been provided a usable account of that process or its results. I question why there should be substantial disputes over vehicle classification in cases where the VIN, make, model, year, and manufacturer's weight label should permit verification.
The towing contract appears to contemplate detailed records, including GPS information and tow documentation. Yet FOI responses have, in my understanding, denied that the City has custody or control of certain records. My attempts to request a VPD investigation were redirected, and I was unable to obtain even the occurrence or reference number I requested to document the complaint.
The Auditor's office subsequently said it was satisfied such problems were rare. I do not know what underlying records or sampling supported that conclusion, particularly given the 13 tow records I had supplied. I believe a genuinely independent audit must explain its methodology, obtain original tow and billing records, inspect the classifications and refunds, and distinguish isolated mistakes from recurring practices.
4. WHY THE POTENTIAL SCALE WARRANTS INDEPENDENT INVESTIGATION
For illustration only, if a company handled 50,000 relevant tows per year over 28 years, and if every one involved $100 in excess charges, the arithmetic would be $140 million (50,000 × 28 × $100). The volume, time span, prevalence and average excess amount in that example are NOT established by my sample, and this is NOT a proven loss figure. It demonstrates why accurate historical tow counts and a representative independent invoice audit matter. If other charging mechanisms also produce excess fees, the exposure could differ significantly.
I suspect the combination of opaque invoices, inaccessible records, delayed explanations, partial refunds and institutional reluctance to scrutinize the matter may be protecting more than accidental errors. I worry about possible collusion, kickbacks and entrenched financial interests, but I have no direct evidence establishing a kickback scheme or the complicity of named officials. Those are questions for independent investigators, not conclusions I can responsibly certify.
5. MY FEAR OF RETALIATION AND MY REQUEST TO THE MEDIA
My campaigning and public protest have been unusually visible, including taking my RV to City Hall, painting large protest lettering on it, and calling for a full accounting. I was a mayoral candidate in 2026 and intend to continue raising this issue, including in the lead-up to 2030.
I am increasingly afraid that continued scrutiny could lead to retaliation, including an arrest, detention, injury, or even violence against me. I fear something may happen within the next two weeks. This is my prediction and fear, not evidence that anyone has planned to harm me, and I cannot identify a person who has made such a plan. I want my concern documented openly in advance, not treated as proof of a conspiracy.
I ask CBC, the Vancouver Sun, CityNews, the Mayor, Council and the appropriate independent oversight bodies to review the invoices, corrected classifications, refunds, contract, complaint correspondence and records-access responses now. Please ask Busters, City staff, the Auditor and VPD for their accounts; verify the figures independently; preserve relevant records; and insist on a transparent, methodologically credible audit.
I want public accountability, accurate refunds for any proven overcharges, and a safe way to continue lawful criticism and protest.
Scott Gilbert
greatscottgilbert@gmail.com
Link to this email
Sent · 1:17 am Vancouver time
Follow-up: speaker left at Busters office
Hi Jim and Justin,
I'm following up on my email yesterday about the powered speaker I left at the office when I postponed my protest for Remembrance Day.
I arrived today to charge it and set up, but it was no longer where I left it. Staff mentioned it might have been moved to the other office.
Could you please check whether a staff member moved it and let me know where I can collect it? If not, I'd appreciate it if you could check and preserve any relevant security footage to help establish who moved it.
Thanks very much for your help.
Scott Gilbert
Link to this email