November 10, 2026

Return to the full correspondence index

Reply or case update · 3:32 pm Vancouver time

RE: Updated Busters audit request — 16 misclassified tows; 8 not refunded

From  Whistleblowing <Whistleblowing@vancouver.ca>

To  Scott Gilbert

Date in the email  Tue, 10 Nov 2026 22:32:28 +0000

Dear Scott, Thanks for your patience as we obtained further information from the City related to your complaint, including on how staff provide oversight over operations at the City Impound Lot managed by Busters. In your follow up email, you expressed concerns that Buster’s may be systematically overbilling vehicle owners by classifying their vehicles in higher weight categories. That is the component of your complaint that potentially falls within the scope the City’s Whistleblower Policy that we administer independently. Through our preliminary assessment work we have determined that such errors appear to be rare, with yours being some of only a handful of vehicles misclassified in recent times. Evidence and explanations from the City’s Engineering Services department, which manages the City’s relationship with Busters, point to misclassification of vehicles being legitimate errors, rather than something intentional or frequent. City staff provided us with a list of misclassifications that have occurred recently, and explanations of why they were initially placed in the incorrect weight category. The information shared gave us the necessary confidence that the City has sufficient oversight over Busters’ operations at the Impound Yard that the City’s actions do not meet the criteria for a finding of serious wrongdoing (a defined term in the Whistleblower Policy). We are therefore unable to investigate your complaint further. I can understand the frustration you have expressed in your emails with being overcharged several times for tows. Unfortunately, as stated in my previous email to you, our Office does not investigate the fairness of the City’s actions like an ombudsperson’s office would, or provide an appeals function for disputes. I am pleased to hear that some of your incorrect tow charges have been appropriately refunded, and encourage you to continue to work with Busters to find a resolution to any remaining issues you’re facing or explore an avenue for recovering costs such as the Civil Resolution Tribunal if Busters resists your claims. We appreciate you raising process and governance-related questions about the City’s management of parking enforcement and impoundment as well. These fall under the broader mandate of the Office of the Auditor General to conduct performance audits which support Council’s stewardship over public funds. Performance audits look at processes more generally, and how they could be improved at a system-level, which differs from examining instances of serious wrongdoing, as our whistleblowing team does. As previously stated, we have shared your concerns with the Auditor General for consideration as he updates the OAG’s Audit Plan, which will be released publicly early next year. If the Auditor General does select this as a topic for a performance audit, we can inform you via email. Thank you again for your complaint to our whistleblowing team. We hope you can find a quick and satisfactory resolution to your disputes with Busters and obtain further refunds where relevant. Best regards, Varun Varun Banthia (he/him) Senior Auditor (Whistleblowing) Office of the Auditor General | City of Vancouver whistleblowing@vancouver.ca<mailto:whistleblowing@vancouver.ca> This email contains information that is CONFIDENTIAL. Any use of this communication by an unintended recipient is strictly prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient, please notify us by telephone and destroy this email. I acknowledge that this email is being sent from the unceded traditional territories of the xʷməθkʷəy̓əm (Musqueam), Sḵwx̱wú7mesh (Squamish), and səlilwətaɬ (Tsleil-Waututh) Nations.
Earlier correspondence included in the email
From: Scott Gilbert <[email address omitted]> Sent: Thursday, November 5, 2026 1:00 PM To: Whistleblowing <Whistleblowing@vancouver.ca> Cc: Office of the Auditor General <OAG@vancouver.ca> Subject: Updated Busters audit request — 16 misclassified tows; 8 not refunded Dear Varun, This is a material update to my request for a Busters Towing contract-oversight investigation. In your October 30 reply you said you would look into whether the classification problems I reported are systemic. Busters has now confirmed Dear Varun, This is a material update to my request for a Busters Towing contract-oversight investigation. In your October 30 reply you said you would look into whether the classification problems I reported are systemic. Busters has now confirmed to me that its records contain EIGHT tows of my GMC motorhome and EIGHT tows of my Grumman. According to that confirmation, ALL SIXTEEN were misclassified in the higher towing-weight category. Only HALF have been refunded to date; eight remain unresolved. I request that your office verify the complete list directly against Busters' original and corrected invoices. I can provide the vehicle particulars and supporting correspondence. Busters had previously corrected five GMC tows from Category 3 to 2 and calculated a $719.23 refund. The additional transactions make it difficult to characterize this as an isolated mistake. Please investigate: (1) why classifications were repeatedly wrong across two vehicles; (2) whether other customers were similarly charged and whether refunds are being issued without a complaint; (3) the basis for additional "load/secure," standby and multiple fuel-surcharge entries, using historical rate schedules; (4) why the City referred me to Busters for records even though its contract provides reporting, inspection and audit rights; (5) the rise in City-reported vehicle/equipment towing expenditure from $1,111,659 in 2021 to $1,477,809 in 2023; and (6) whether City-paid services, owner-paid impounds, property fees and contractor revenues have been correctly separated and reconciled. For scale, an explicitly hypothetical routine-fleet breakdown model yielded about $47,100 annually, versus the City's reported $1.48 million in 2023. This is not an estimate of all City towing services; I ask for the actual service counts and cost categories explaining the approximately $1.43 million difference. The City's November 2024 report supplies its figures: https://council.vancouver.ca/20241113/documents/cfsc4.pdf Please also examine procurement safeguards and verify publicly reported historical political contributions before drawing any conclusions about conflicts. I make no allegation that a contribution proves improper influence. Please preserve the dispatch data, invoices, vehicle class entries, edit histories, tariff versions, driver records, complaints, refunds and City contract-management records. I ask for reconsideration of your earlier assessment and a written explanation of what independent inquiries you can undertake. Regards, Scott Gilbert [email address omitted]<mailto:[email address omitted]> [phone number omitted]

Link to this email

Reply or case update · 9:55 am Vancouver time

RE: Notice of Peaceful Demonstrations — November 6–7, 2026

From  DHILLON, Kam <kam.dhillon@vpd.ca>

To  Great Scott Gilbert <greatscottgilbert@gmail.com>

Cc  COOPER, Christopher <chris.cooper@vpd.ca>, YOUNG, Cesar <cesar.young@vpd.ca>, NILAUSEN, Thomas <TOM.NILAUSEN@vpd.ca>

Date in the email  Tue, 10 Nov 2026 16:55:46 +0000

Good morning, Mr. Gilbert, We just wanted to follow-up on your demonstration on Friday. Did everything go well? Any issues that you want to share with our unit? Please let us know as we value any feedback. Also, can you please confirm what hours you were set up. Thanks again, Kam Detective Constable 1941 Kam DHILLON Vancouver Police Department 3585 Graveley Street Vancouver, BC, V5K 5J5 Email: kam.dhillon@vpd.ca<mailto:kam.dhillon@vpd.ca> Phone: work [phone number omitted] cell [phone number omitted] Fax: [phone number omitted]
Earlier correspondence included in the email
From: VPD Protests Mailbox Sent: Thursday, November 05, 2026 8:47 AM To: Great Scott Gilbert <greatscottgilbert@gmail.com> Cc: COOPER, Christopher <chris.cooper@vpd.ca>; YOUNG, Cesar <cesar.young@vpd.ca>; NILAUSEN, Thomas <TOM.NILAUSEN@vpd.ca> Subject: RE: Notice of Peaceful Demonstrations — November 6–7, 2026 Good morning, Mr. Gilbert, Given the information you have provided I do not foresee any issue with your planned protest. The fact that you have already stated that you will not be impeding business and/or traffic has already addressed the issues our office would have concerns with. If you have any further concerns or questions, please reach out to me. Kam Detective Constable 1941 Kam DHILLON Vancouver Police Department 3585 Graveley Street Vancouver, BC, V5K 5J5 Email: kam.dhillon@vpd.ca<mailto:kam.dhillon@vpd.ca> Phone: work [phone number omitted] cell [phone number omitted] Fax: [phone number omitted] From: Great Scott Gilbert <greatscottgilbert@gmail.com<mailto:greatscottgilbert@gmail.com>> Sent: Thursday, November 05, 2026 8:17 AM To: VPD Protests Mailbox <protests@vpd.ca<mailto:protests@vpd.ca>> Cc: Jim.Dent@busterstowing.com<mailto:Jim.Dent@busterstowing.com>; justin.schrump@busterstowing.com<mailto:justin.schrump@busterstowing.com>; David.Cheung2@vancouver.ca<mailto:David.Cheung2@vancouver.ca> Subject: Notice of Peaceful Demonstrations — November 6–7, 2026 Message from an external sender Do not open attachments or click on links, unless you recognize the sender's email address and know the content is safe. Hello VPD Planning Assessment Team, I am providing advance notice of my intention to hold a peaceful demonstration outside Vancouver City Hall on Friday, November 6, 2026, potentially for the full day. The demonstration concerns disputed historical towing charges, vehicle classifications and contractor oversight involving Busters Towing and the City of Vancouver. I may hold additional peaceful demonstrations on public property outside Busters Towing beginning November 7. I intend to avoid obstructing entrances, sidewalks, vehicle traffic and emergency access. Please advise of any site-specific safety considerations, conflicting events or applicable requirements. I understand that peaceful assembly itself does not ordinarily require a protest permit. For context, five towing invoices were corrected in October 2026, resulting in a $719.23 refund. I continue to dispute charges on other historical invoices and request a documented investigation and refunds for verified overpayments. Please acknowledge receipt of this notice and identify a contact for any necessary coordination. Scott Gilbert [phone number omitted] [email address omitted]<mailto:[email address omitted]>

Link to this email

Sent · 7:36 am Vancouver time

Re: Your Request for Information - Scott Gilbert - VFRS 109 E Hastings fire

From  Great Scott Gilbert <greatscottgilbert@gmail.com>

To  foi@vancouver.ca

Date in the email  Tue, 10 Nov 2026 14:36:52 +0000

Dear City FOI Office, Thank you for your November 9 response. Please open and process the personal-information portion of my November 8 request independently of the general-information portion. I am referring specifically to item 5: VFRS and City records concerning the fire at or behind 109 East Hastings Street on or about August 20, 2023 that contain my personal information, including my reports and evidence, recorded threats against me or my family, safety assessments, decisions and referrals, and related correspondence mentioning me. The original request gives my name, identifying email addresses, incident location and date range, and additional search locators. My own personal-information request is exempt from fees under FIPPA section 75(3). The City's FOI instructions <https://vancouver.ca/your-government/make-a-freedom-of-information-request.aspx> also permit submission by email. Please preserve November 8 as the receipt date, assign a file number, and identify any specific clarification or secure identity-verification step needed. I am not authorizing a paid fire report or general-information processing by this reply; those may be addressed separately. If the City maintains that the personal-information request cannot be opened from the November 8 email, please state the legal or bylaw basis and identify precisely what information is missing. Sincerely, Scott Gilbert
Earlier correspondence included in the email
On Mon, 09 Nov 2026 16:48:00 +0000, Freedom of Information Office <FreedomOfInformation@vancouver.ca> wrote: Hello Scott, Thank you for your email. Please note that the Freedom of Information requests for Vancouver Fire Rescue Services (VFRS) is correctly handled by the City’s FOI department, and therefore FOI request submissions for general information are subject to a $10.00 application fee. Please resubmit your request as a General Information request using the webform found on the City of Vancouver’s website here: https://vancouver.ca/your-government/make-a-freedom-of-information-request.aspx. The webform allows for payment via credit card when submitting your request. Once your request and payment have been received, our office can begin processing your request. Please note that Fire Incident Reports are routinely available for a fee from VFRS and are therefore not subject to the Act. To obtain the routinely available for a fee record, please contact VFRS by following the instructions at the following link: https://vancouver.ca/home-property-development/request-a-fire-incident-report.aspx. Fire Incident Reports include the information created from a Fire Investigation. For any request for personal information, please clearly state the records being requested that contain your personal information when submitting the webform at the link noted above. If your request for records remains unclear, our office may require further clarification which can cause delays to processing. If you have any questions, please email us at foi@vancouver.ca<mailto:foi@vancouver.ca> and we will respond to you as soon as possible. You may also contact 3-1-1 ([phone number omitted]) if you require accommodation or do not have access to email. *See Item 3 within Schedule 1 of the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy By-law No. 11451<https://bylaws.vancouver.ca/11451c.pdf> for reference. As this request requires a fee payment before processing may commence, an access to information request case file has not been created at this time. Regards, From: Great Scott Gilbert <greatscottgilbert@gmail.com> Sent: Sunday, November 8, 2026 4:04 AM To: Freedom of Information Office <FreedomOfInformation@vancouver.ca> Subject: FIPPA request — VFRS 109 E Hastings fire of approximately 20 August 2023: investigation file and chronology Dear City of Vancouver Access to Information and Privacy Office, Please route this FIPPA request to Vancouver Fire Rescue Services, including its Fire Investigation function and any relevant records held centrally by the City. I request electronic Dear City of Vancouver Access to Information and Privacy Office, Please route this FIPPA request to Vancouver Fire Rescue Services, including its Fire Investigation function and any relevant records held centrally by the City. I request electronic copies of existing records concerning the fire at or behind 109 East Hastings Street on or about 20 August 2023, reported to police as arson, and VFRS's subsequent investigation and communications with VPD, including David Silverstein. I am Scott Lawrence Allen Gilbert / Scott Gilbert, DOB 18 February 1983. I assisted with a lock change at this property, reported associated threats, supplied information and assisted with fire restoration. My interest includes my own personal information, joint records and the releasable non-personal incident and investigation records. I do not assert that the cause, suspect identity, arrest or charge outcome has been established. Date range: 1 August 2023 through 8 November 2026 for this incident and linked investigation/communications. The reported 20 August date appears in a 28 September 2023 email in “Space available for winter shelter” correspondence with City Housing/Homelessness staff, including Dustin Lupick. A related 11 October 2023 email from Victoria Mansfield described video/audio provided to VPD and continuing threats. If the fire is indexed to an adjacent date, please assist in identifying it by address and these locators. Please provide: 1. Dispatch/CAD/event and incident numbers, call/dispatch audio and metadata still retained, incident histories/audit trails, attendance/arrival/clearance times, responding apparatus and personnel, and the complete fire incident report. 2. All fire-investigation reports, drafts and amendments; investigator notebooks/electronic notes; origin-and-cause findings and classifications; supporting photographs, video, scene diagrams, measurements, laboratory/expert results, evidence/property/continuity records, and recorded limitations or alternative causes. 3. The investigator assignment and task/action chronology, scene attendance and follow-up, witness statements/interviews and records evaluating or forwarding CCTV/video/audio supplied by me or others. 4. Communications, referrals, evidence-sharing and coordination with VPD, including David Silverstein, the Office of the Fire Commissioner and other public bodies concerning this fire, suspected arson, related threats or safety concerns. Include any VFRS-held records noting an arrest, charge recommendation, Crown charge approval, charges laid or an outcome, and the associated police/court identifiers. Please distinguish what VFRS independently determined from what it was told by someone else. 5. Records containing my personal information, my reports/evidence and recorded threats against me or my home/vehicle/family, any safety assessments and decisions or referrals arising from them. If held, include correspondence mentioning Nextdoor / Next Door and my request for a response from David Silverstein. 6. Existing chronological investigation summaries, status/disposition/closure/reopening records and recorded reasons, from first report to the latest follow-up. Preserve original timestamps and identify the timezone where recorded. 7. Any existing record-retention/destruction records for responsive material no longer held, and the applicable retention schedule. Search locators include Scott Lawrence Allen Gilbert / Scott Gilbert; greatscottgilbert@gmail.com<mailto:greatscottgilbert@gmail.com>; [email address omitted]<mailto:[email address omitted]>; [email address omitted]<mailto:[email address omitted]>; [email address omitted]<mailto:[email address omitted]>; [phone number omitted] and former [phone number omitted]; Victoria Mansfield; James, the leaseholder/venue operator; 109 E/109 East Hastings; basement/storage occupant; eviction/lock change/locksmith; gasoline/dumpster; fire/arson; David Silverstein. This seeks the investigative file and chronology, beyond merely ordering a standard one-page fire incident report. Please identify any responsive record available routinely without fees and provide the remaining records under FIPPA. If any earlier City/VFRS request by me overlaps, identify its reference/status and cross-reference it without withdrawing it, resetting an earlier receipt date or duplicating work. Please preserve responsive records still held against routine deletion during processing. I understand preservation cannot restore material already destroyed. Please identify systems/custodians and date ranges searched, apply reasonable severing and cite the legal basis for withholdings. Please process my own personal information and reasonably severable joint records under the section 75(3) personal-information fee exemption. If any requested additional portion is general information, identify it separately and advise any application/processing requirement before incurring charges. I request consideration of a fee waiver under section 75(5) based on inability to afford the cost and the public-safety interest in records of a reported fire/arson and follow-up. No paid report order or chargeable work is authorized without my express agreement. Please progress the personal portion independently. Please advise the secure identity-verification method you require, including an alternative if original photo ID is unavailable. Correspond and deliver records electronically to greatscottgilbert@gmail.com<mailto:greatscottgilbert@gmail.com>; I currently have no reliable mailing address. I am also submitting a separate request to VPD for its records; that does not replace this City/VFRS request. Please acknowledge receipt, provide a reference and identify any outstanding identity or fee requirement. Sincerely, Scott Lawrence Allen Gilbert greatscottgilbert@gmail.com<mailto:greatscottgilbert@gmail.com>

Link to this email

Sent · 4:55 am Vancouver time

Please forward inquiry to other 2026 Vancouver mayoral candidates

From  Great Scott Gilbert <greatscottgilbert@gmail.com>

To  Vancouver Election <election@vancouver.ca>

Date in the email  Tue, 10 Nov 2026 03:55:24 -0800

Hello Election Office, I was a candidate for Mayor of Vancouver in 2026. I received the attached undated letter apparently from MP Terry Beech congratulating me on participating in the election. Would you kindly forward this inquiry and the attached photograph to the other seven mayoral candidates, or provide their publicly designated campaign contact information if forwarding is not possible? I am asking whether they received the same or a substantially similar letter, and if so, whether it was dated and when it arrived. Replies can be sent directly to me at greatscottgilbert@gmail.com. This is simply a comparison and verification request; I am not alleging that the letter is improper. Thank you, Scott Gilbert
Attachment filenames (1)
  • 1663.jpg

Link to this email