Outstanding towing overcharges — $719.23 breakdown and response required by noon November 2
From Scott Gilbert
To Jim Dent <Jim.Dent@busterstowing.com>, Justin Schrump <justin.schrump@busterstowing.com>
Date in the email Sun, 1 Nov 2026 05:22:42 -0800
Hi Jim and Justin,
Please provide an invoice-by-invoice, line-by-line breakdown of the $719.23 refund identified in Justin's October 19 email. That email gives $1,639.57 in original charges less $920.34 in revised charges, but does not show how each revised invoice was calculated.
For tow jobs 3810392, 3807932, 3792106, 3789702 and 3786533, please provide the original and revised invoices, each amount retained or refunded, the rate and quantity used for every fee, each fuel-surcharge calculation, GST, storage dates and payments or credits. Explain any difference between those totals and my payment records. Please also reconcile your calculation with my October 7 accounting: that document used a different refund scenario, including removal of the July 20 charge and additional fees, and is not the same calculation as your class-only adjustment.
My position is that several hundred dollars remain outstanding. Correcting the weight class does not resolve my separate dispute over the additional charges.
Jim, my recollection of your explanation was that additional charges apply for "anything over ten minutes." My position is that this explanation does not, by itself, establish authority to charge standby, Load/Secure Vehicle and a second fuel surcharge together. Please identify the precise bylaw, applicable contract provision or tariff in force on each tow date that you rely on for each charge. Provide the contemporaneous start/finish times, work descriptions, driver and dispatch records, and any required authorization. Explain whether standby and loading/securing time overlapped, what was already included in the base tow, and the fee base to which each fuel surcharge was applied.
The City's published public-property towing fees are here:
https://vancouver.ca/streets-transportation/impounded-vehicles-and-towing-fees.aspx
My position is that the invoices should be reduced to the applicable Category 2 tow charges listed there, including the applicable published fuel charge and GST, plus no more than one day of storage per tow. I dispute the remaining extras and storage beyond that. If you say a different schedule or tow category applies to a particular job, identify it and provide the underlying tow authorization and supporting records. The current webpage is a comparison point; please identify the rates actually applicable on each tow date.
Unless I receive written confirmation by 12:00 noon on Monday, November 2, 2026, Vancouver time, that you will refund the remaining amounts claimed on that basis, I will file a Civil Resolution Tribunal claim for the disputed balance. Please state the further refund amount and payment date. I am not treating the $719.23 adjustment as a full resolution of my claim.
There is also the earlier 1991 Grumman-Olson, registered to Victoria Mansfield, which we used. I am certain that every Busters tow of that vehicle that I am referring to was billed at Category 3. My position is that its documented weight placed it in Category 2. When it was sold in early 2024, I complained about the Category 3 charge and showed the weight tag, but no refund was issued. I attribute our loss of that vehicle to the high impound costs.
I no longer have those receipts. Please retrieve the invoices, weight/classification records, photographs, payment and sale records, and complaint/refund records under Victoria Mansfield's name. Recalculate the charges, identify the resulting refund and arrange payment to the proper payee. If you require authorization from Victoria to disclose records or process a refund, specify exactly what is required.
The Office of the Auditor General advised on October 30 that it would seek further information about the City's oversight of Busters and assess whether the issues may be systemic and fall within the Whistleblower Policy. A formal investigation has not been confirmed. I want the Grumman records addressed now rather than left for a possible oversight review. Please preserve the relevant records for both vehicles, including original invoice versions and changes.
You can also use my TowAudit web preview free of charge:
https://towaudit-web-preview.blush-eel-4267.chatgpt.site/
I have arranged viewing access for both of your email addresses. It is intended to help compare vehicle weight classes and base tow rates and reduce repeat misclassification. Where a lookup is incomplete, check the driver's-door or coach-builder GVWR label and its units before assigning a class.
Please respond to both the remaining-refund demand and the Grumman records request by the deadline above.
Regards,
Scott Gilbert
[email address omitted]
[phone number omitted]