RE: Audit request — Busters Towing vehicle-class billing and City contract oversight
From Whistleblowing <Whistleblowing@vancouver.ca>
To Scott Gilbert
Date in the email Fri, 30 Oct 2026 22:00:07 +0000
Dear Scott,
Thanks for your email, and for providing us with more details about how you were charged for tows and your experience with obtaining refunds for incorrectly classified tows. I recognize how these circumstances could cause considerable stress, given the price difference between the two weight categories. I also acknowledge your requests for additional information from us.
I am going to seek some more information to understand the oversight the City provides on the third-party contractor’s administration of towing, and then to determine if/how the issues you raise may then fall within the scope of the Whistleblower Policy. The objective is to see to what extent your experience is a systemic issue rather than a one-off based on a unique set of circumstances and whether the City is exercising appropriate oversight over Busters under its contract.
Once I’ve gathered that additional information, I will provide you with a further update. I do want to note though that the OAG Whistleblower Program is not a general complaints investigation or Ombudsperson scheme- we can only investigate issues within the mandate under the Policy. We try to add value wherever we can, but the type of issues we can investigate is limited. Whatever the outcome of our additional enquiries I will update you by email as soon as possible.
Again, we appreciate you bringing these issues to our attention.
Best regards,
Varun
Varun Banthia (he/him)
Senior Auditor (Whistleblowing)
Office of the Auditor General | City of Vancouver
whistleblowing@vancouver.ca<mailto:whistleblowing@vancouver.ca>
This email contains information that is CONFIDENTIAL. Any use of this communication by an unintended recipient is strictly prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient, please notify us by telephone and destroy this email.
I acknowledge that this email is being sent from the unceded traditional territories of the xʷməθkʷəy̓əm (Musqueam), Sḵwx̱wú7mesh (Squamish), and səlilwətaɬ (Tsleil-Waututh) Nations.
Earlier correspondence included in the email
From: Scott Gilbert <[email address omitted]>
Sent: Friday, October 23, 2026 1:36 PM
To: Office of the Auditor General <OAG@vancouver.ca>
Subject: Re: Audit request — Busters Towing vehicle-class billing and City contract oversight
Dear Anna, Thank you for your October 23 response. I request a copy of the “formal mechanism” for disputing vehicle weights on which your Office relied, and reconsideration of the decision not to proceed under the Whistleblower Policy. I appreciate
Dear Anna,
Thank you for your October 23 response. I request a copy of the “formal mechanism” for disputing vehicle weights on which your Office relied, and reconsideration of the decision not to proceed under the Whistleblower Policy. I appreciate that the broader issues remain available for consideration in audit planning.
Please provide:
1. The written weight-classification dispute procedure, including its creation date, effective date, previous versions relevant to my tows, and any City approval. If there is no written procedure, please say so. Schedule A, section 4.5 of the publicly released City–Busters agreement requires operating procedures for the bylaw-impound and abandoned-vehicle sites to be submitted for City approval, with prior approval for amendments.
2. The exact date and time of the call described as “last Wednesday,” the person contacted and their position, and whether they were employed by the City or Busters. Please provide the call notes and any related correspondence or documents, and explain precisely what was said about the process. Did your team inspect a written policy or completed dispute files, or rely on an oral description? When and how did your Office first learn of this mechanism?
3. Where and since when the process has been communicated to vehicle owners: office signage, invoices, website pages or other notices. Please identify the evidence requirements, reviewer, response deadlines, appeal route, refund rules, and treatment of accumulating storage charges while a classification is disputed.
There is significant evidence missing from the account in your response. On October 19, Busters’ Fleet Manager Justin Schrump confirmed in writing that five tows had been reduced from Class 3 to Class 2. He reduced the total from $1,639.57 to $920.34, a difference of $719.23. The tow-job numbers were 3810392, 3807932, 3792106, 3789702 and 3786533.
Busters’ explanation was that a manufacturer’s marking of 8,900 had been interpreted as kilograms instead of pounds. That is their explanation, which should be tested against the original photographs and billing records. Your response instead describes a process based on the VIN and publicly available vehicle information. Please establish which method was actually used for each tow and how the repeated higher classification survived the company's checks.
If “last Wednesday” means October 21, your team's call occurred after Busters had already confirmed these corrections. Was that correspondence obtained and considered before your Office concluded there was no immediate reason for concern?
I have previously challenged Busters over weight classification on a different vehicle and was never told of a dispute process during those dealings. In the present matter, Justin did send an October 8 email requesting documents and offering a review within 7–10 business days. I acknowledge that correspondence. My concern is whether a pre-existing, accessible process was disclosed and operated when customers challenged charges, and whether it prevented or detected repeated overbilling.
The rate schedule was also absent from public display during my earlier visits. I had not seen it displayed over a period of years. Only this week, after I insisted, staff reluctantly reposted an old schedule that I understand had previously been taken down. Please verify when it was removed and restored. Schedule A, section 4.6 requires rates and fees to be posted clearly visibly to the public at the storage facilities, and drivers to carry the current schedule for public inspection on request. Without the schedule and weight categories, customers are poorly placed to recognize misclassification.
My experience at the counter has been that staff say, in substance, that the driver submitted the invoice, Busters must pay it, and therefore I must pay it too. Requests to speak to the driver have been refused. I have been told I must pay to recover my vehicle or face increasing daily storage charges, and subsequently told there are no refunds. I have also disputed being charged after a written commitment to a one-time free release, subject to proof of ownership. Those experiences need to be reconciled with the process described to your team.
My understanding is that drivers are treated as contractors and paid a percentage of revenue. Please verify the actual compensation arrangements and examine whether a higher classification increases the driver's payment, who approves the classification, and what independent checks exist. This raises a potential financial incentive for overcharging. Calling drivers contractors does not answer who controls and is accountable for the charges demanded from customers.
I encountered repeated higher classifications across different drivers and more than one vehicle. Earlier complaints did not produce an effective resolution. I ultimately escalated the matter through a protest at City Hall with my RV; police directed me to move and assured me I would receive a reply. The eventual correction of five bills does not establish that ordinary customers have an accessible or effective remedy.
I believe this pattern warrants investigation as possible deliberate overcharging and criminal fraud. Knowingly using false classifications to obtain money could engage section 380 of the Criminal Code<[email-security redirect omitted]>. Whether that occurred requires investigation of the records and the people responsible. The existence of a refund mechanism does not resolve that question or account for customers who never discover the error.
Please reconsider the Whistleblower decision in light of this evidence, explain what further evidence your Office requires, and identify the appropriate referral route for suspected criminal conduct. My request for independent scrutiny stands separately from recovery of the remaining disputed charges.
Please preserve your assessment and call records and seek preservation of the relevant classification records, invoice histories, source photographs, compensation arrangements, complaints and refunds. Please acknowledge this reply and provide the requested documents and a substantive response within 10 business days, or advise when they can be provided.
The publicly released agreement referenced above is available here:
https://vancouver.ca/files/cov/2021-324-release.pdf
(Schedule A sections 4.5 and 4.6: PDF page 57.)
Regards,
Scott Gilbert
[email address omitted]<mailto:[email address omitted]>
[phone number omitted]
On Fri, 23 Oct 2026 20:10:29 +0000, Office of the Auditor General <OAG@vancouver.ca<mailto:OAG@vancouver.ca>> wrote:
Dear Scott, Thank you for your correspondence of September 28, 2026 to the City of Vancouver’s Office of the Auditor General (OAG). Request for a Performance Audit We acknowledge receipt of your request that the Auditor General consider the towing and record-keeping practices of Buster’s Towing, a City contractor, as a topic for a future performance audit. We appreciate your suggestion and will raise the broader procurement and contracting issues with the Auditor General for consideration when he reviews the OAG’s Audit Plan later this year. However, for transparency, we did not find any immediate reason for concern when the impound yard staff outlined their processes to us; we discuss this further in the section below. It is therefore unlikely that a performance audit of that area would be a priority for our relatively small team. The Audit Plan is published on January 30 each year. We encourage you to visit the Auditor General’s webpage<https://vancouver.ca/your-government/auditor-general.aspx> on or after that date to see which audits are planned for 2027 through to the end of the Auditor General’s term in 2028. Do note that performance audits typically look at the overall economy, efficiency and effectiveness of government operations rather than specific incidents. While your experience may be considered within that broader context, an audit would not investigate or report specifically on the incidents you mentioned. I also note that our Office has plans to review the City's approach to enforcement of its Impoundment By-law, so we may be able to consider the issues you raise as part of that work. Request for Review Under the City of Vancouver Whistleblower Policy As you noted, consideration of your complaint under the Whistleblower Policy (COUN-010) is another potential option. For this purpose, I confidentially forwarded your report to the OAG Whistleblower Team for an initial assessment. This is the first step in the process for determining whether the concerns you raise could, on their face, rise to the high bar of “serious wrongdoing” necessary to proceed with a preliminary assessment. Last Wednesday, the team called the City Impound Yard to inquire about its process for estimating gross vehicle weight for the purpose of determining towing fees. The team was informed that this estimate is based on the Vehicle Identification Number (VIN) and publicly available information about the weight of that particular vehicle. However, we learned that the impound yard has a formal mechanism in place for vehicle owners to dispute this estimated weight, and that refunds are provided for a portion of the fee when sufficient evidence of a discrepancy is provided. Given the existence of this dispute mechanism, and that the Whistleblower Policy is not intended to duplicate the functions of other City departments, we will not be proceeding further under the Whistleblower Policy. We suggest that you contact the City Impound Yard at [phone number omitted] to inquire about the process for disputing the weights recorded on the invoices you received. If, after proceeding through that process, you still believe there is a governance issue that could amount to “serious wrongdoing,” we could reconsider the issue, but there would need to be compelling evidence of that. Thank you again for your engagement with the Office of the Auditor General for the City of Vancouver. Best regards, Anna On behalf of the Office of the Auditor General This email contains information that is CONFIDENTIAL. Any use of this communication by an unintended recipient is strictly prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient, please notify us and destroy this email. ________________________________ From: Scott Gilbert <[email address omitted]<mailto:[email address omitted]>> Sent: 28 September 2026 20:18 To: Office of the Auditor General <OAG@vancouver.ca<mailto:OAG@vancouver.ca>> Subject: Audit request — Busters Towing vehicle-class billing and City contract oversight Dear Office of the Auditor General, I am requesting that the Office consider an independent performance and compliance audit of the City of Vancouver’s administration and oversight of the municipal towing contract with All Tech Transport Ltd. , Dear Office of the Auditor General, I am requesting that the Office consider an independent performance and compliance audit of the City of Vancouver’s administration and oversight of the municipal towing contract with All Tech Transport Ltd., doing business as Busters Towing. My immediate concern is repeated use of a higher vehicle-weight classification when Busters tows my 1976 GMC Vandura motorhome, BC plate [plate omitted]. The manufacturer certification plate states a GVWR of 10,000 lb, or approximately 4,536 kg. However, Busters invoice 3807932 for the September 14, 2026 tow records the vehicle as “Group 3,” defined on the invoice as over 6,300 kg to 9,072 kg. I paid $303.08 on that invoice. A July 27 receipt also records Group 3. In my experience, the same higher classification has been used every single time this motorhome has been towed recently, across different tow drivers and incidents, including tows on or about July 10, July 20, July 27, September 14 and September 22. The documents currently in my possession expressly show Group 3 on the July 27 and September 14 transactions; I am asking that the source invoices and system records be examined to confirm the classification used on every other tow. Because the same vehicle and licence plate have repeatedly passed through Busters’ dispatch, yard and billing systems, and because management has now received written notice of the dispute, this should not be treated solely as a possible one-off driver error. The recurrence across different operators raises a reasonable question whether the classification results from a billing-system default, a company instruction, training, inadequate controls, or a practice known to management. I am not asking the Office to presume fraud or criminal wrongdoing. I am asking for a records-based audit capable of determining whether the public has been charged in accordance with the City contract and applicable bylaw rates. I ask that the proposed audit include: 1. Reconciliation of every Busters tow involving plate [plate omitted], including the weight/class recorded, the source used for that classification, the driver and dispatcher identifiers, the applicable tariff, and a line-by-line recalculation of the invoice. 2. Review of additional “load/secure,” release/unhook, equipment, standby, fuel-surcharge, storage and second-truck charges to determine whether any fee was unsupported, duplicated or calculated using the wrong vehicle class. 3. A statistically meaningful sample of other Busters municipal tows, particularly motorhomes, vans and vehicles assigned to Groups 2 and 3, including transactions that never generated a complaint. 4. Analysis of complaints, corrected invoices, refunds, chargebacks, damage claims and repeated classification issues by driver, dispatcher and billing code. 5. Assessment of whether City contract administrators actually review Busters’ dispatch, GPS, vehicle-weight, tow-method, invoice and daily-report data, and whether documented breaches have resulted in corrective action. 6. Public reporting of aggregate findings, together with reimbursement of confirmed overcharges and controls preventing recurrence. Please also ensure that relevant dispatch logs, invoice histories and edits, rate tables, vehicle-class fields, photographs, GPS data, communications, complaint records, refund records and contract-management records are preserved. City FOI file 2026-655 concerns related towing records and may assist in locating the relevant material. Please acknowledge this request, advise whether it will be considered during audit planning or referred for preliminary assessment, and identify any additional records the Office requires from me. Regards, Scott Gilbert [email address omitted]<mailto:[email address omitted]><mailto:[email address omitted]<mailto:[email address omitted]>> [phone number omitted]