November 16, 2026

Return to the full correspondence index

Reply or case update · 4:00 pm Vancouver time

Your Request for Information - Scott Gilbert - RE: FOI request — origin, policy development, enforcement, deterrence alternatives, and art-program connections for Vancouver Graffiti By-law No. 7343

From  Freedom of Information Office <FreedomOfInformation@vancouver.ca>

To  scottgilbertvan

Cc  Freedom of Information Office <FreedomOfInformation@vancouver.ca>

Date in the email  Mon, 16 Nov 2026 23:00:57 +0000

Hello Scott, Thank you for your email and my sincere apologies for the delayed reply. FOI request submissions for general information are subject to a $10.00 application fee. Please resubmit your request as a General Information request using the webform found on the City of Vancouver’s website here: https://vancouver.ca/your-government/make-a-freedom-of-information-request.aspx. The webform allows for payment via credit card when submitting your request. Once your request and payment have been received, our office can begin processing your request. If you have any questions, please email us at foi@vancouver.ca<mailto:foi@vancouver.ca> and we will respond to you as soon as possible. You may also contact 3-1-1 ([phone number omitted]) if you require accommodation or do not have access to email. *See Item 3 within Schedule 1 of the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy By-law No. 11451<https://bylaws.vancouver.ca/11451c.pdf> for reference. As this request requires a fee payment before processing may commence, an access to information request case file has not been created at this time. Please note for future reference that any requests for general information require a $10.00 application fee prior to our office creating and processing a file under FIPPA. Regards, Kevin Tuerlings FOI Case Manager Access to Information & Privacy | City of Vancouver foi@vancouver.ca<mailto:foi@vancouver.ca>
Earlier correspondence included in the email
From: Scott Gilbert <[email address omitted]> Sent: Thursday, May 7, 2026 1:29 AM To: Freedom of Information Office <FreedomOfInformation@vancouver.ca> Subject: FOI request — origin, policy development, enforcement, deterrence alternatives, and art-program connections for Vancouver Graffiti By-law No. 7343 Draft Vancouver FOI request Subject: FOI request — origin, policy development, enforcement, deterrence alternatives, and art-program connections for Vancouver Graffiti By-law No. 7343 To: foi@ vancouver. ca To the City of Vancouver Corporate Information Draft Vancouver FOI request Subject: FOI request — origin, policy development, enforcement, deterrence alternatives, and art-program connections for Vancouver Graffiti By-law No. 7343 To: foi@vancouver.ca<mailto:foi@vancouver.ca> To the City of Vancouver Corporate Information and Privacy Office: I am requesting access to records under the Freedom of Information and Protection of Privacy Act concerning the creation, amendment, policy rationale, enforcement, and related art/community programming connected to the City of Vancouver’s Graffiti By-law No. 7343 and related graffiti-management programs. Please provide electronic copies of the following records. 1. Origin of Vancouver Graffiti By-law No. 7343 For the period January 1, 1990 to December 31, 1995, please provide records concerning the proposal, drafting, approval, and implementation of Graffiti By-law No. 7343, including: Council reports, committee reports, staff reports, briefing notes, memoranda, backgrounders, presentations, and attachments. Draft versions of the bylaw and any marked-up versions showing changes. Records identifying who proposed or requested the bylaw, including councillors, mayoral office staff, City staff, Vancouver Police Department representatives, Business Improvement Areas, property-owner groups, contractors, consultants, security companies, community organizations, or other outside parties. Records explaining the policy rationale for making property owners or occupiers responsible for graffiti removal when they did not create the graffiti. Records discussing legal authority, Vancouver Charter authority, constitutional issues, property-rights issues, freedom-of-expression issues, public-art issues, or fairness concerns related to requiring innocent owners or occupiers to remove graffiti. Any public consultation records, correspondence, submissions, petitions, complaints, survey results, or records of public meetings concerning the proposed bylaw. Any records comparing Vancouver’s proposed bylaw to other municipalities in British Columbia, Canada, or the United States. 2. 2001–2004 anti-graffiti strategy and amendments For the period January 1, 2000 to December 31, 2004, please provide records concerning anti-graffiti strategies, proposed amendments, enforcement policy, and interdepartmental work related to Graffiti By-law No. 7343, including: Records related to the 2001 and 2002 anti-graffiti proposals referenced in the March 26, 2002 Vancouver Police Department report to Council. Records authored by, sent to, or received from City Engineering, Licences and Inspections, City Clerk’s Office, Legal Services, Sanitation / Streets, or any anti-graffiti program staff concerning graffiti policy. Records involving Vancouver Police Department representatives, including but not limited to anti-graffiti team proposals, Youth Squad involvement, school liaison involvement, graffiti databases, study flags, Crown prosecution strategy, restorative justice, and security-company coordination. Records concerning proposed or actual amendments to Graffiti By-law No. 7343, including any records concerning By-law No. 8539 or amendments regulating removal from private property. Records concerning the cost, enforcement, penalties, fine amounts, cost recovery, or economic impact on businesses, property owners, BIAs, Chinatown, the Downtown Eastside, or other commercial districts. Any records discussing whether enforcement against property owners was chosen instead of, or in addition to, enforcement against taggers or spray-paint vandals. 3. Deterrence alternatives and spray-paint controls For the period January 1, 1990 to December 31, 2004, please provide records concerning options considered to deter graffiti before it occurred, including: Restrictions on the sale, display, storage, or possession of spray paint, markers, etching tools, glass acid, or other graffiti tools. Youth diversion, community service, school credits, restorative justice, probation conditions, restitution, offender billing, or Crown prosecution strategies. CCTV, security patrols, police/security-company databases, intelligence gathering, reporting systems, Crime Stoppers campaigns, or other enforcement/deterrence tools. Mural contests, sanctioned walls, free walls, legal graffiti spaces, hoarding murals, public art initiatives, utility-box art, or other legal-art alternatives. Records explaining why particular deterrence options were accepted, rejected, delayed, or abandoned. 4. Jurisdictional scans across Canada Please provide any records, reports, spreadsheets, briefing notes, memos, emails, or attachments comparing Vancouver’s graffiti bylaw or graffiti-management program to other Canadian municipalities, including but not limited to: Toronto, Montréal, Calgary, Ottawa, Edmonton, Winnipeg, Mississauga, Brampton, Hamilton, Surrey, Victoria, North Vancouver, Burnaby, Richmond, and any other municipalities reviewed by the City. This portion of the request includes records identifying: When other cities first adopted graffiti bylaws or property-owner removal requirements. Whether other cities required property owners to remove graffiti at their own cost. Whether other cities restricted spray-paint sales or storage. Whether other cities funded free removal for private property. Whether other cities used police-led, bylaw-led, contractor-led, youth-diversion, mural, or legal-wall programs. Which municipalities were used as models for Vancouver’s approach. 5. Connections between enforcement, City staff, police, contractors, BIAs, and graffiti-art programming For the period January 1, 2010 to present, please provide records concerning City involvement, police involvement, contractor involvement, BIA involvement, or public funding connected to graffiti art, mural programs, sanctioned graffiti spaces, legal graffiti walls, utility-box wraps, hoarding murals, graffiti-art shows, street-art festivals, or similar programming. Please include records concerning: The Integrated Graffiti Management Program. The Mural Program. Utility-box art-wrap programs. Vancouver Mural Festival or similar mural/street-art events. Legal graffiti walls or sanctioned graffiti zones, including the 133 West Pender Street legal graffiti wall. Any City staff, VPD staff, bylaw staff, contractors, BIAs, or elected officials involved in planning, approving, funding, attending, sponsoring, promoting, or enforcing rules around graffiti-art events or legal walls. Contracts, grants, contribution agreements, sponsorships, conflict-of-interest declarations, procurement records, invoices, and communications involving graffiti-removal contractors, mural contractors, artists, BIAs, or community organizations. Any records discussing whether legal walls, mural programs, or graffiti-art programming reduced illegal tagging, displaced illegal tagging, increased tagging, or had no measurable effect. 6. Enforcement and economic-impact data For the period January 1, 2010 to present, please provide records showing annual totals for: Graffiti complaints received. Orders or notices issued to property owners or occupiers. Tickets or fines issued to property owners or occupiers. Tickets, charges, or referrals issued to persons alleged to have placed graffiti. City removals from private property. Amounts billed to property owners. Amounts collected from property owners. Amounts written off, waived, cancelled, appealed, or not collected. Complaints, appeals, or correspondence from businesses or BIAs objecting to being required to pay for graffiti caused by third parties. Any records concerning suspension, relaxation, waiver, or non-enforcement of owner-removal fines, including during or after the COVID-19 pandemic. 7. Contractors and private interests For the period January 1, 2000 to present, please provide records concerning contracts, procurement, payments, evaluations, complaints, audits, or correspondence involving graffiti-removal contractors or service providers, including but not limited to Goodbye Graffiti and any predecessor or related contractors. Please include: Requests for proposals, bid documents, contracts, amendments, invoices, and payment summaries. Performance reviews, complaint records, service-level records, and environmental-compliance records. Records concerning chemical removal methods, paint-over methods, environmental best practices, drainage/storm sewer concerns, or occupational-safety concerns. Records concerning any contractor role in advising on policy, enforcement, bylaw amendments, public communications, or BIA programming. Search terms Please search, at minimum, the following terms: “graffiti”, “tagging”, “tagger”, “spray paint”, “spray-paint restrictions”, “etching”, “glass acid”, “mischief”, “Graffiti By-law 7343”, “By-law 8539”, “anti-graffiti”, “Graffiti Busters”, “Integrated Graffiti Management Program”, “Mural Program”, “utility box art”, “art wrap”, “legal wall”, “free wall”, “sanctioned graffiti”, “Vancouver Mural Festival”, “hoarding mural”, “Rock Solid”, “Business Improvement Area”, “BIA”, “Goodbye Graffiti”, “Leadcore”, “security companies”, “Crime Stoppers”, “Crown”, “restorative justice”, “Transformative Justice”, “Wendy Hawthorne”, “Rowan Birch”, “Steve Elson”, “Detective Constable”, “Youth Squad”, “School Liaison”, “private property”, “property owner”, “cost recovery”, “fine”, “order”, “notice to comply”. Custodians / departments Please search records held by or accessible to: City Clerk’s Office; Legal Services; Engineering Services; Licences and Inspections; Sanitation / Streets; Arts, Culture and Community Services; Planning, Urban Design and Sustainability; Integrated Graffiti Management Program; Communications; Finance; Procurement; Social Policy; the Mayor’s Office; Councillor offices where searchable; and any City liaison records involving VPD, Vancouver Police Board, BIAs, TransLink, contractors, or community organizations. Format and fee management Please provide records electronically in PDF, Excel, CSV, or native electronic format where available. If the City anticipates a fee estimate, please first provide: A record count or index by category. The departments searched or proposed to be searched. The date ranges searched. The estimated number of pages or files. Options to narrow the request while preserving records about bylaw origin, decision-makers, deterrence alternatives, and connections to graffiti-art programming. Please do not exclude records merely because they contain some personal information; please sever personal information where required and disclose the remainder. Sincerely, Scott Gilbert

Link to this email

Reply or case update · 2:12 pm Vancouver time

City of Vancouver - FOI File no. 2026-655 - res 2

From  Freedom of Information Office <FreedomOfInformation@vancouver.ca>

To  Great Scott Gilbert <greatscottgilbert@gmail.com>

Cc  Freedom of Information Office <FreedomOfInformation@vancouver.ca>

Date in the email  Mon, 16 Nov 2026 21:12:06 +0000

Hello Scott, Thank you for your e-mail. Our office has reviewed the records package provided to you in response to your request and can confirm that pages 1 to 9 (of 13) were provided to you in error and do not relate to the matter you had requested. We apologize for the oversight and confusion caused as a result. Parking Enforcement staff have advised our office that the Buster’s Towing reference number you had provided (‘786533’) is unrelated to your matter, and resulted in the provision of incorrect parking infraction records. Your follow-up e-mail dated November 12, 2026, in which you provided the licence plate number of your vehicle, allowed Parking Enforcement staff to identify the specific towing issues you had initially requested. Parking Enforcement staff advised our office that the two impounds identified are not related to Parking Enforcement; both impounds were initiated by Vancouver Police Department (VPD) and occurred on July 10, 2026 (PC 3802) and July 20, 2026 (PC 3556). As these were VPD-related impounds, the City does not have any additional information regarding the circumstances of the impoundment. Please contact VPD for further details, or if requesting records, visit their website for more information: https://vpd.ca/contact-us/information-privacy/. Regarding the response provided to you on September 25, 2026, our office can confirm that 3-1-1 advised our office that they have no records since towing requests go directly to Parking Enforcement; 3-1-1 does not create a case for those calls. Additionally, we can confirm that pages 10 and 11 (of 13) contain correspondence following the July 29, 2026 response you received from the City Clerk’s Office, and no additional portions of that correspondence can be disclosed. Attached, please find an updated response letter and records which reflect the corrected response to your request. I hope you find this information helpful. Regards, Kevin Tuerlings FOI Case Manager Access to Information & Privacy | City of Vancouver foi@vancouver.ca<mailto:foi@vancouver.ca>
Earlier correspondence included in the email
From: Great Scott Gilbert <greatscottgilbert@gmail.com> Sent: Thursday, November 12, 2026 2:32 PM To: Freedom of Information Office <FreedomOfInformation@vancouver.ca> Subject: FOI 2026-655 — wrong vehicle records and outstanding supplemental search Dear Access to Information and Privacy Division, I am following up on my September 26 request for a supplemental search in City FOI 2026-655. I have not located a substantive response. Your September 25 letter correctly describes my two GMC Dear Access to Information and Privacy Division, I am following up on my September 26 request for a supplemental search in City FOI 2026-655. I have not located a substantive response. Your September 25 letter correctly describes my two GMC motorhome tows, near Powell and Heatley on July 10, 2026 (Busters reference 786533, job 3786533), and near Main and Terminal on July 20 (job 3789702). The operational records in the package instead show the same Evo Toyota at 600 National Avenue and 100 East Pender Street, tickets GY87520 and GZ11145. My own notice about the GMC appears later in the package. Please confirm how those ticket numbers were matched to my request and whether their inclusion was an error. If they were included in error, please let me know whether your privacy office assessed the release and whether you will issue a corrected package. Please search the relevant City systems using GMC plate [plate omitted], both dates and locations, and the Busters references. Identify the units and systems searched and the identifiers used, including the City’s own dispatch, daily towing reports, Parking Enforcement, 311, and contract-management and claims records. Please explain whether each requested category of contractor records is under City control, including what access the operative contract provides, and identify any appropriate custodian for records the City does not hold or control. For the full-page s. 14 redaction (PDF page 12) and the redaction at the top of PDF page 13, please identify the record type and date where possible and confirm whether any reasonably severable portion can be released. Please acknowledge receipt and reply to this address. Scott Gilbert greatscottgilbert@gmail.com<mailto:greatscottgilbert@gmail.com>
Attachment filenames (1)
  • 2026-655 - res 2.pdf

Link to this email

Reply or case update · 9:55 am Vancouver time

RE: Please forward inquiry to other 2026 Vancouver mayoral candidates

From  Vancouver Election <election@vancouver.ca>

To  Great Scott Gilbert <greatscottgilbert@gmail.com>

Date in the email  Mon, 16 Nov 2026 16:55:26 +0000

Hi Scott, Thank you for taking the time to reach out to the Election Office. Unfortunately, we will not be able to pass along your message to the other mayoral candidates, as we would only contact candidates when required to for official City-related business. You will need to contact them on your end. You can find a list of the other candidates’ names on the City webpage, here<https://vancouver.ca/your-government/2026-candidate-information.aspx>, by clicking the tab labelled “Mayor”. If you have any issues with the webpage, please reach back out to us for assistance. Best Regards, Election Team City of Vancouver Election Office Website: Vancouver.ca/vote<vancouver.ca/votes> I am grateful to live and work on the unceded traditional territories of the xʷməθkʷəy̓əm (Musqueam), Sḵwx̱wú7mesh Úxwumixw (Squamish), and səlilwətaɬ (Tsleil-Waututh) Nations.
Earlier correspondence included in the email
From: Great Scott Gilbert <greatscottgilbert@gmail.com> Sent: Tuesday, November 10, 2026 4:55 AM To: Vancouver Election <election@vancouver.ca> Subject: Please forward inquiry to other 2026 Vancouver mayoral candidates Hello Election Office, I was a candidate for Mayor of Vancouver in 2026. I received the attached undated letter apparently from MP Terry Beech congratulating me on participating in the election. Would you kindly forward this inquiry and the Hello Election Office, I was a candidate for Mayor of Vancouver in 2026. I received the attached undated letter apparently from MP Terry Beech congratulating me on participating in the election. Would you kindly forward this inquiry and the attached photograph to the other seven mayoral candidates, or provide their publicly designated campaign contact information if forwarding is not possible? I am asking whether they received the same or a substantially similar letter, and if so, whether it was dated and when it arrived. Replies can be sent directly to me at greatscottgilbert@gmail.com<mailto:greatscottgilbert@gmail.com>. This is simply a comparison and verification request; I am not alleging that the letter is improper. Thank you, Scott Gilbert

Link to this email

Automated notice · 3:08 am Vancouver time

Mayor and Council Feedback Case Created - #201003771727

From  van311-no-reply@vancouver.ca

To  Great Scott Gilbert <greatscottgilbert@gmail.com>

Date in the email  Mon, 16 Nov 2026 03:08:31 -0700 (GMT-07:00)

Your "Mayor and Council Feedback Case" has been created. Your case reference number is 201003771727 <[private access link omitted]> Your comment has been sent to City Council and may be forwarded to City staff for action when appropriate. If a response is required, you will receive an email reply within 10 business days. You may follow-up on the status of your request anytime using the case number above at https://van311.ca/my-requests To protect your privacy, visible case details will be limited unless you are logged in to an account associated with the same provided email. We recommend creating an account for an optimal case follow-up experience. Create an account with Van311 <https://van311.ca/my-account?register=true> Download the Van311 app <https://vancouver.ca/van311> or visit Van311.ca <https://van311.ca/> to submit new requests. Your case summary Type of feedback: General feedback Subject: Busters Towing Address: 425 INDUSTRIAL AV Provide details: Busters towing is running a racket and I have deconstructed what they are doing and obtained confirmation from the company that every single one of 13 tow spanning multiple years, two vehicles and many drivers ALL were misclassified by weight adding an average of $140 to each bill, and that is just one of several padding tactics they use. They claim this is a rare mistake - it is not. They tell the City auditor there is a process in place to obtain a refund if a mistake was made - they gave me a partial refund once after over 100 days of trying repeatedly to get this done and when I subsequently provided payment records for a second vehicle they did this so they stopped responding and now won't even give me a print out of the dates and amounts for that vehicle. The city auditor has declined to take this matter on and so have the VPD. If you read the Google reviews this company has a long history of overcharging many people and telling people they do not issue refunds and the full balance must be paid to get your vehicle back. It appears to me VPD is compromised and the auditor may be as well. The scale of the loss to Vancouver vehicle owners is surely over $10 million and possibly over $200 million in the past 28 years. The city has denied access to records that the contract with busters says they do have and this is starting to smell like a case of serious corruption that may result in criminal charges against busters management, VPD and even the auditor. To clear these people and resolve the unknowns council must act quickly to resolve this through an independent review that can clear Busters Towing, the Office of the Auditor General, and the VPD where the evidence supports it, or pinpoint what went wrong and hold those responsible accountable. Vancouver residents deserve confidence in their elected officials, local government, police, and oversight bodies. Start with a focused, low-cost invoice audit. Use the City’s contractual audit rights to have an outside firm compare actual tow invoices year by year with the amounts authorized by the by-law and contract and the maximum a reasonable person would have understood from the City’s fee page at the time. Account for approved rate and fuel surcharge changes, verify vehicle weight classes, and check charges such as “load and secure.” Test for both a sustained jump and a mismatch dating back to the earliest available records. Give this first phase a modest budget and a short deadline, and preserve the underlying records now. Follow the evidence. If the audit finds widespread discrepancies, determine how they arose, who knew, how complaints were handled, and what refunds or corrections are owed. Retain independent outside legal counsel to assess the findings and recommend whether to refer the matter to a police agency outside the VPD or ask the Province for a public inquiry. If the evidence points to possible criminal conduct by anyone, including VPD leadership or the City’s Auditor General, refer it for independent investigation and leave any charging decision to Crown counsel. Report publicly and answer questions. Release the audit findings and outside counsel’s assessment to the fullest extent legally permitted. Hold a press conference where I and other members of the public can ask questions and receive answers about the findings and next steps. My peaceful demonstrations throughout next week will focus on making the case for this preliminary independent audit. A short, modestly budgeted review can help determine whether a forensic audit or a public inquiry is warranted. I hope everyone receiving this will support getting a clearer picture of what happened. During the recent municipal election, I was running for mayor while living in my vehicle. I repeatedly lost access to it for days at a time under impound holds whose basis I dispute Neighbourhood: Downtown To opt out of all emails, sign up or log in to Van311.ca <https://van311.ca/my-account> to manage your notification preferences.

Link to this email