FIPPA request — VFRS 109 E Hastings fire of approximately 20 August 2023: investigation file and chronology
From Great Scott Gilbert <greatscottgilbert@gmail.com>
To foi@vancouver.ca
Date in the email Sun, 8 Nov 2026 06:04:02 -0500
Dear City of Vancouver Access to Information and Privacy Office,
Please route this FIPPA request to Vancouver Fire Rescue Services, including its Fire Investigation function and any relevant records held centrally by the City.
I request electronic copies of existing records concerning the fire at or behind 109 East Hastings Street on or about 20 August 2023, reported to police as arson, and VFRS's subsequent investigation and communications with VPD, including David Silverstein. I am Scott Lawrence Allen Gilbert / Scott Gilbert, DOB 18 February 1983. I assisted with a lock change at this property, reported associated threats, supplied information and assisted with fire restoration. My interest includes my own personal information, joint records and the releasable non-personal incident and investigation records. I do not assert that the cause, suspect identity, arrest or charge outcome has been established.
Date range: 1 August 2023 through 8 November 2026 for this incident and linked investigation/communications. The reported 20 August date appears in a 28 September 2023 email in “Space available for winter shelter” correspondence with City Housing/Homelessness staff, including Dustin Lupick. A related 11 October 2023 email from Victoria Mansfield described video/audio provided to VPD and continuing threats. If the fire is indexed to an adjacent date, please assist in identifying it by address and these locators.
Please provide:
1. Dispatch/CAD/event and incident numbers, call/dispatch audio and metadata still retained, incident histories/audit trails, attendance/arrival/clearance times, responding apparatus and personnel, and the complete fire incident report.
2. All fire-investigation reports, drafts and amendments; investigator notebooks/electronic notes; origin-and-cause findings and classifications; supporting photographs, video, scene diagrams, measurements, laboratory/expert results, evidence/property/continuity records, and recorded limitations or alternative causes.
3. The investigator assignment and task/action chronology, scene attendance and follow-up, witness statements/interviews and records evaluating or forwarding CCTV/video/audio supplied by me or others.
4. Communications, referrals, evidence-sharing and coordination with VPD, including David Silverstein, the Office of the Fire Commissioner and other public bodies concerning this fire, suspected arson, related threats or safety concerns. Include any VFRS-held records noting an arrest, charge recommendation, Crown charge approval, charges laid or an outcome, and the associated police/court identifiers. Please distinguish what VFRS independently determined from what it was told by someone else.
5. Records containing my personal information, my reports/evidence and recorded threats against me or my home/vehicle/family, any safety assessments and decisions or referrals arising from them. If held, include correspondence mentioning Nextdoor / Next Door and my request for a response from David Silverstein.
6. Existing chronological investigation summaries, status/disposition/closure/reopening records and recorded reasons, from first report to the latest follow-up. Preserve original timestamps and identify the timezone where recorded.
7. Any existing record-retention/destruction records for responsive material no longer held, and the applicable retention schedule.
Search locators include Scott Lawrence Allen Gilbert / Scott Gilbert; greatscottgilbert@gmail.com; [email address omitted]; [email address omitted]; [email address omitted]; [phone number omitted] and former [phone number omitted]; Victoria Mansfield; James, the leaseholder/venue operator; 109 E/109 East Hastings; basement/storage occupant; eviction/lock change/locksmith; gasoline/dumpster; fire/arson; David Silverstein.
This seeks the investigative file and chronology, beyond merely ordering a standard one-page fire incident report. Please identify any responsive record available routinely without fees and provide the remaining records under FIPPA. If any earlier City/VFRS request by me overlaps, identify its reference/status and cross-reference it without withdrawing it, resetting an earlier receipt date or duplicating work.
Please preserve responsive records still held against routine deletion during processing. I understand preservation cannot restore material already destroyed. Please identify systems/custodians and date ranges searched, apply reasonable severing and cite the legal basis for withholdings.
Please process my own personal information and reasonably severable joint records under the section 75(3) personal-information fee exemption. If any requested additional portion is general information, identify it separately and advise any application/processing requirement before incurring charges. I request consideration of a fee waiver under section 75(5) based on inability to afford the cost and the public-safety interest in records of a reported fire/arson and follow-up. No paid report order or chargeable work is authorized without my express agreement. Please progress the personal portion independently.
Please advise the secure identity-verification method you require, including an alternative if original photo ID is unavailable. Correspond and deliver records electronically to greatscottgilbert@gmail.com; I currently have no reliable mailing address. I am also submitting a separate request to VPD for its records; that does not replace this City/VFRS request.
Please acknowledge receipt, provide a reference and identify any outstanding identity or fee requirement.
Sincerely,
Scott Lawrence Allen Gilbert
greatscottgilbert@gmail.com