November 5, 2026

Return to the full correspondence index

Reply or case update · 4:21 pm Vancouver time

Re: Follow-up: Busters invoice surcharges, $1.48M City towing expenditure, and contract audit records

From  Justin Schrump <justin.schrump@busterstowing.com>

To  Scott Gilbert

Cc  David.Cheung2@vancouver.ca, Jim.Dent <Jim.Dent@busterstowing.com>

Date in the email  Thu, 5 Nov 2026 23:21:15 +0000

Hello Scott, We will review your information and provide you with an answer by the end of the business day tomorrow. If you have any other vehicles being held at Buster’s Towing impound, please let us know. You also forwarded an invoice to our staff today for review, I’m having difficulty understanding the request related to it. The name associated with the release and license plate is not Scott Gilbert, but another name that we are not at liberty to disclose. Could you please clarify what you are requesting regarding the invoice? Best regards
Earlier correspondence included in the email
From: Scott Gilbert <[email address omitted]> Date: Thursday, November 5, 2026 at 10:30 AM To: David.Cheung2@vancouver.ca <David.Cheung2@vancouver.ca>; Jim.Dent <Jim.Dent@busterstowing.com>; Justin Schrump <justin.schrump@busterstowing.com> Subject: Follow-up: Busters invoice surcharges, $1.48M City towing expenditure, and contract audit records Dear David, Jim and Justin, I am following up on the five towing invoices that Busters corrected from Category 3 to Category 2, resulting in a $719.23 refund on October 19. I appreciate that correction, but the remaining extra charges are disputed. The public records also raise broader questions about the City’s payments, recordkeeping and audit controls. I ask for a substantive, itemized written response, not an assumption that any impropriety has already been established. 1. Specific fuel-surcharge and extra-service charges on my receipts. The July 10, 2026 bill (total $557.16) contains a $34.39 fuel surcharge on the base tow and a separate $51.59 fuel surcharge associated with additional services; the September 14 invoice #3807932 ($303.08) contains $37.15 in fuel surcharge on the tow and a further $18.57 associated with $68.79 “Load/Secure Vehicle.” The July 27 invoice #3794199 likewise has $37.15 and $18.57 fuel entries. What specific Impounding By-law section, operative tariff, contractual provision or authorized rate interpretation permits fuel surcharges on each of those separately billed extras in a completed public-street bylaw impound? Please show the applicable percentage and calculation base as of each tow date, and distinguish a lawful surcharge applied once to multiple eligible components from any charge applied twice to the same service. The City’s public fee webpage currently says 27% fuel surcharge is “applied to all fees” for public tows, whereas the 2020 contract’s attached ICBC rate schedule addresses fuel surcharges on specified charges. Please explain precisely which schedule governs customer invoices and which governs City-paid services, and how the separate additional services themselves were authorized. A general statement that a surcharge applies to an authorized fee does not establish that the underlying extra fee was justified. The 2020 agreement’s attached ICBC schedule describes “loading and securing” beyond 10 minutes in circumstances involving damage (such as a vehicle broken into pieces or requiring tarping). Identify the scene photographs, damage condition, actual added work, timing and tariff authority supporting “load/secure” and standby on my particular tows, rather than ordinary hook-up work already included in the base rate. Please provide a line-by-line recalculation and refund of any unsupported amounts (currently I estimate approximately $500 remains in dispute, subject to reconciliation). 2. City expenditure growth. The City’s November 13, 2024 report (RTS 16536, p. 5) reports towing costs of $1,111,659 in 2021, $1,377,388 in 2022 and $1,477,809 in 2023 — a 32.9% increase from 2021 to 2023. Please identify annual service volumes, rates, contractor payments and cost components behind that increase; distinguish vehicle breakdowns/collisions, special recoveries, planned equipment moves, civilian vehicle relocations, investigative tows and any standing/administrative fees. These are City-reported towing expenditures and should not automatically be equated with Busters-only revenue without a vendor reconciliation. 3. Test against a modest fleet breakdown model. A preliminary illustrative, not measured model using the City’s published 2022 fleet/equipment asset counts (Engineering 740, Parks 300, Police 440, Fire 128; 1,608 assets total), assumed annual breakdown/accident tow frequencies of 8%, 5%, 12% and 8%, respectively, and assumed average charges of $400, $250, $250 and $650, yields approximately 137 routine tows and $47,100 per year. The assumptions may be wrong, some assets are not road vehicles, and the City’s broader towing costs may cover many additional functions. That is precisely why actual tow counts, fee categories, average charges and explanations of the approximately $1.43 million difference from the 2023 reported total are required. What were the actual vehicle and equipment counts and City-paid tows, by department and reason, in 2021–2025? 4. Owner charges versus City invoices. The January 2004 Council report describes approximately $400,000 in City departmental towing expenses (including Parking Enforcement), yet separately says vehicle owners paid their own impoundments at no cost to the City. The February 2020 contract similarly requires collection of bylaw tow fees from owners and reports to the City, while authorizing City payment for specified other services. Please reconcile these categories and identify whether there are any charges payable by both the City and owners for a single dispatch, and what controls prevent unreconciled duplicate collection. Please distinguish towing fees, storage charges collected on behalf of the City, drop charges, and City-paid fleet/police/relocation work. 5. Contractor records and City responsibility. David’s October 7 response referred me to Busters as best positioned to verify VIN, weight classification, photographs and billing. Yet the released 2020 agreement requires a next-business-day Excel record of every bylaw impound (section 5.2©), contractor records available for inspection (section 4.1(n), within 48 hours of request), management reports (section 7), and City access to service accounts and audits (section 8.5). Please identify the responsible contract administrator, what records the City has already obtained, and why it could not independently review the disputed class/charge data. If any record is unavailable, identify the record type, contractual retention rule, custodian, search performed, and any corrective action. 6. City payments and property licence fees. The 2019 award estimated City service expenditure of $6.615 million and City lease/licence revenue of $5.082 million over seven years. The 2020 contract section 5.2(l)(ii) sets beginning monthly site-licence fees of at least $40,000 for 425 Industrial Avenue and $20,500 for 455 Industrial Avenue ($726,000 annually combined, before adjustments). Please identify actual amounts billed/received for each property and actual City payments by fiscal year, including extensions, concessions, insurance recoveries and escalation terms. Were the lease terms independently appraised? 7. Oversight and next steps. Please preserve relevant invoices, dispatch entries, original and adjusted fee codes, photos, rate versions, daily Excel reports, payment/credit records and audit trails. Please provide a written, item-by-item answer within ten business days, identify who is accountable for investigating systemic contract compliance (not just my own refund), and state whether an independent sample audit will be conducted. I am also sending a distinct targeted FOI request for existing municipal finance, fleet towing and property records; it is not a request to Busters to disclose private customer information. Sources for reference: City 2004 contract renewal: https://council.vancouver.ca/20040127/a3.pdf 2019 award: https://council.vancouver.ca/20191002/documents/cfsc4.pdf 2020 agreement (FOI 2021-324): https://vancouver.ca/files/cov/2021-324-release.pdf 2024 Council report: https://council.vancouver.ca/20241113/documents/cfsc4.pdf City fee page: https://vancouver.ca/streets-transportation/impounded-vehicles-and-towing-fees.aspx Sincerely, Scott Gilbert [phone number omitted] [email address omitted]<mailto:[email address omitted]>

Link to this email

Sent · 12:59 pm Vancouver time

Updated Busters audit request — 16 misclassified tows; 8 not refunded

From  Scott Gilbert

To  whistleblowing@vancouver.ca

Cc  Office of the Auditor General <oag@vancouver.ca>

Date in the email  Thu, 5 Nov 2026 11:59:55 -0800

Dear Varun, This is a material update to my request for a Busters Towing contract-oversight investigation. In your October 30 reply you said you would look into whether the classification problems I reported are systemic. Busters has now confirmed to me that its records contain EIGHT tows of my GMC motorhome and EIGHT tows of my Grumman. According to that confirmation, ALL SIXTEEN were misclassified in the higher towing-weight category. Only HALF have been refunded to date; eight remain unresolved. I request that your office verify the complete list directly against Busters' original and corrected invoices. I can provide the vehicle particulars and supporting correspondence. Busters had previously corrected five GMC tows from Category 3 to 2 and calculated a $719.23 refund. The additional transactions make it difficult to characterize this as an isolated mistake. Please investigate: (1) why classifications were repeatedly wrong across two vehicles; (2) whether other customers were similarly charged and whether refunds are being issued without a complaint; (3) the basis for additional "load/secure," standby and multiple fuel-surcharge entries, using historical rate schedules; (4) why the City referred me to Busters for records even though its contract provides reporting, inspection and audit rights; (5) the rise in City-reported vehicle/equipment towing expenditure from $1,111,659 in 2021 to $1,477,809 in 2023; and (6) whether City-paid services, owner-paid impounds, property fees and contractor revenues have been correctly separated and reconciled. For scale, an explicitly hypothetical routine-fleet breakdown model yielded about $47,100 annually, versus the City's reported $1.48 million in 2023. This is not an estimate of all City towing services; I ask for the actual service counts and cost categories explaining the approximately $1.43 million difference. The City's November 2024 report supplies its figures: https://council.vancouver.ca/20241113/documents/cfsc4.pdf Please also examine procurement safeguards and verify publicly reported historical political contributions before drawing any conclusions about conflicts. I make no allegation that a contribution proves improper influence. Please preserve the dispatch data, invoices, vehicle class entries, edit histories, tariff versions, driver records, complaints, refunds and City contract-management records. I ask for reconsideration of your earlier assessment and a written explanation of what independent inquiries you can undertake. Regards, Scott Gilbert [email address omitted] [phone number omitted]

Link to this email

Delivery notice · 12:42 pm Vancouver time

Delivery Status Notification (Failure)

From  Mail Delivery Subsystem

To  Scott Gilbert

Date in the email  Thu, 05 Nov 2026 11:42:11 -0800 (PST)

** Address not found ** Your message wasn't delivered to [email address omitted] because the address couldn't be found, or is unable to receive mail. Learn more here: https://support.google.com/mail/?p=NoSuchUser The response was: 550 5.1.1 The email account that you tried to reach does not exist. Please try double-checking the recipient's email address for typos or unnecessary spaces. For more information, go to https://support.google.com/mail/?p=NoSuchUser 98e67ed59e1d1-3b0d7a0f154sor240304a91.1 - gsmtp
Attachment filenames (1)
  • icon.png

Link to this email

Sent · 12:42 pm Vancouver time

Re: Next refund — historical rates and private criminal Information

From  Scott Gilbert

To  Jim Dent <Jim.Dent@busterstowing.com>, Justin Schrump <justin.schrump@busterstowing.com>

Cc  david.cheung2@vancouver.ca, investigate, citydesk

Bcc  globalbc.newstips, ConsumerMatters, vancouver, tips, editor, bob, editorial, bcassign, news, mail, globalnational, cbcnewsvancouver

Date in the email  Thu, 5 Nov 2026 11:42:10 -0800

Jim, Justin and David, This supplements the “Next refund” email I sent earlier today. I want to clarify the historical rate schedule and give formal notice that I intend to seek judicial review of possible criminal fraud through a private Information. HISTORICAL 2023 RATES: The City's publicly released August 1, 2023 amendment to the Busters towing agreement (FOI 2023-484, Appendix 1) sets a Category 2 (3,000–6,300 kg GVW) regular municipal tow at $84.25, with a 27% fuel surcharge on the specified towing rates, and storage of $23.98 per day for vehicles 20 feet or shorter. These are different base and storage fees from today's published schedule. The effective rates must be established separately for May 3, July 20, and September 19, 2023, and for each later tow; please provide the exact bylaw version, applicable schedule and computation for each invoice, rather than applying current charges retrospectively. The legal basis must also distinguish City bylaw, private-property, ICBC accident and provincial impoundment tows. 2023 rate source: https://vancouver.ca/files/cov/2023-484-release.pdf (Appendix 1) CRIMINAL-LAW NOTICE: I am preparing to lay a private Information under section 504 of the Criminal Code, to be considered under section 507.1, concerning possible fraud under section 380. The issues for examination include whether vehicle-weight classifications or additional-fee descriptions were knowingly misstated to collect money not due. I will ask that investigators assess any evidence of concerted, repeated conduct under the legal definition of a criminal organization in section 467.1 and the related sections 467.11–467.13. That is a request for independent examination, not an assertion that any named individual or organization is already proven guilty of those offences. Issuing refunds and considering criminal evidence are independent matters. No refund is a condition for avoiding a report, and a disputed invoice alone does not prove criminal intent. The strongest response is full disclosure of the original data, showing exactly what was known and authorized at the time. Please preserve all original and revised invoices, GVWR photographs, dispatch records, classification and driver notes, customer objections, records of any changes to the invoicing system, staff instructions, contract versions, fee schedules, and all records of the October 19 adjustment of five tows from $1,639.57 to $920.34 (a $719.23 refund). Please supply the itemized outstanding accounting, including the Grumman-Olson vehicle for VIN [VIN omitted], by the response dates in my prior email. I intend to pursue all lawful civil, oversight and criminal-information procedures to secure an independent determination of these matters. Regards, Scott Gilbert [email address omitted] [phone number omitted]

Link to this email

Delivery notice · 12:28 pm Vancouver time

Delivery Status Notification (Failure)

From  Mail Delivery Subsystem

To  Scott Gilbert

Date in the email  Thu, 05 Nov 2026 11:28:11 -0800 (PST)

** Address not found ** Your message wasn't delivered to [email address omitted] because the address couldn't be found, or is unable to receive mail. Learn more here: https://support.google.com/mail/?p=NoSuchUser The response was: 550 5.1.1 The email account that you tried to reach does not exist. Please try double-checking the recipient's email address for typos or unnecessary spaces. For more information, go to https://support.google.com/mail/?p=NoSuchUser 98e67ed59e1d1-3b0d7a1600esor228244a91.1 - gsmtp
Attachment filenames (1)
  • icon.png

Link to this email

Sent · 12:28 pm Vancouver time

Next refund

From  Scott Gilbert

To  Jim Dent <Jim.Dent@busterstowing.com>, Justin Schrump <justin.schrump@busterstowing.com>

Cc  david.cheung2@vancouver.ca, investigate, citydesk

Bcc  globalbc.newstips, ConsumerMatters, vancouver, tips, editor, bob, editorial, bcassign, news, mail, globalnational, cbcnewsvancouver

Date in the email  Thu, 5 Nov 2026 11:28:08 -0800

Jim, Justin, and David, Please treat this as a formal demand for an invoice-by-invoice audit, correction of any overcharges, and a full accounting of the towing and impoundment of the vehicle associated with VIN [VIN omitted]. I am copying newsrooms because the documentary issues raise a legitimate question about whether similar billing errors have affected other Vancouver vehicle owners. The attached 2023 ICBC registration identifies a 1991 Chevrolet P30 (Grumman-Olson-bodied step van) and records a net weight of 3,300 kg and gross vehicle weight of 4,950 kg. A gross weight of 4,950 kg falls within the City's published 3,000–6,300 kg towing bracket, commonly described as Category 2. My recollection is that I challenged a Category 3 classification when this vehicle was impounded and was told to pay the driver's assessed classification despite the weight documentation. Please identify every tow of this VIN in your records and the classification used. The attached payment screenshots include Busters payments of $524.69 and $591.89 on September 19, 2023; $377.09 on July 20, 2023; and $126.92 on May 3, 2023. These show payments, not a complete itemized account of each tow. I am asking you to match each payment to its underlying invoice and explain the legal basis for every charge. This follows Busters' October 19 correction of five other tow charges, from $1,639.57 originally billed to $920.34 revised, resulting in a $719.23 refund. That correction is significant, but I still have not received the invoice-by-invoice reconciliation needed to determine whether additional fees, storage, or fuel surcharges were incorrectly retained. Please provide the following for all tows tied to the above VIN and for jobs 3810392, 3807932, 3792106, 3789702, and 3786533: 1. The tow date, location, ordering authority, classification, weight source, vehicle-length assessment, original and revised invoices, payment ledger, and any photographs or driver notes used to classify the vehicle. 2. A dated, line-by-line calculation identifying the governing City bylaw, contractual tariff, private-property provision, or provincial impoundment rule for that particular tow. The City and provincial systems have different base rates, surcharge rules, and storage charges; they cannot simply be interchanged. 3. The exact basis for every standby, loading/securing, dolly, additional-distance, storage, police-hold, and fuel-surcharge entry. Please show time records, distance, service performed, applicable rate, tax treatment, and whether fuel was applied more than once or to a fee not authorized by the governing tariff. 4. A reconciliation of the previously issued $719.23 refund and a calculation of every further amount owed, including any refunds due on the 1991 vehicle. If registered-owner authorization is required to release older records or make payment, please specify the required form promptly. David, I also ask the City to identify who verifies compliance with its Busters agreement, which towing and billing records the City or its contractor holds, and what steps will be taken to review potentially recurring vehicle-weight misclassification and add-on fees. Please preserve all original records and revision histories, dispatch logs, classification photos, invoices, correspondence, and applicable contract/rate schedules. Please acknowledge this request and confirm how any undisputed refund will be paid by 5:00 p.m. Vancouver time on Friday, November 6, 2026. I request the complete written reconciliation and a definitive refund position by Friday, November 13. If Busters disputes any part of my calculation, a documented explanation is far more useful than a general denial. I intend to pursue the available Civil Resolution Tribunal and oversight processes if these matters remain unresolved. I also reserve the right to peaceful public advocacy and to provide the underlying documents to journalists. My concern is accountability for documented billing discrepancies and whether they indicate a wider practice; the evidence, not assumptions about anyone's motives, should determine the outcome. Vancouver's published towing fee reference: https://vancouver.ca/streets-transportation/impounded-vehicles-and-towing-fees.aspx Please reply in writing, retaining all recipients who need to respond. Media recipients are welcome to independently examine the evidence and seek responses from Busters and the City. Regards, Scott Gilbert [email address omitted] [phone number omitted]
Attachment filenames (5)
  • 1452.png
  • 1453.png
  • 1463.png
  • 1461.png
  • 1464.png

Link to this email

Reply or case update · 11:26 am Vancouver time

RE: Ref# 96357-2026 General Local Elections Disclosure Statement

From  Vancouver Election <election@vancouver.ca>

To  Scott Gilbert

Date in the email  Thu, 5 Nov 2026 18:26:04 +0000

Hi Scott, Thank you for your email. The email that you attached is a confirmation of receipt from Election BC. As discussed over the phone, we receive a list from Election BC once they review and process the paperwork. Once we receive confirmation/list directly from Election BC, we will be mailing a cheque ($100 nomination deposit) back to you to your address that was provided in the nomination package. Since the submission of the disclosure ends January 15th 2027, you may connect with us in the new year to follow up regarding your deposit. Thank you, Best Regards, Election Team City of Vancouver Election Office Website: Vancouver.ca/vote<vancouver.ca/votes> [A black background with a black square AI-generated content may be incorrect.] I am grateful to live and work on the unceded traditional territories of the xʷməθkʷəy̓əm (Musqueam), Sḵwx̱wú7mesh Úxwumixw (Squamish), and səlilwətaɬ (Tsleil-Waututh) Nations.
Earlier correspondence included in the email
From: Scott Gilbert <[email address omitted]<mailto:[email address omitted]>> Sent: Thursday, November 5, 2026 2:38 AM To: Vancouver Election <election@vancouver.ca<mailto:election@vancouver.ca>> Subject: Fwd: Ref# 96357-2026 General Local Elections Disclosure Statement Hello Vancouver Election Office, I was a candidate for Mayor in the October 17, 2026 Vancouver election. I am forwarding Elections BC's November 4 acceptance confirmation for my campaign financing disclosure, reference 96357. Elections BC Hello Vancouver Election Office, I was a candidate for Mayor in the October 17, 2026 Vancouver election. I am forwarding Elections BC's November 4 acceptance confirmation for my campaign financing disclosure, reference 96357. Elections BC confirms that the disclosure has been accepted and that no further action is currently required in relation to this report. I am requesting the return of my $100 nomination deposit following my on-time filing, under section 44.1(3)(b) of the Vancouver Charter. I will come by the Election Office today, November 5, 2026, to pick up the deposit. Please reply as soon as possible to confirm that it will be ready for collection, the pickup location and hours, and any identification or receipt I need to bring. Your website lists the Election Office at 305 West 8th Avenue, open 8:30 am to 5 pm. If it cannot be collected today, please confirm in writing when and how the City will return it, including whether it will be refunded to the original payment method, issued by cheque, or returned another way. Thank you, Scott Gilbert 2026 Vancouver mayoral candidate Elections BC reference: 96357

Link to this email

Reply or case update · 10:37 am Vancouver time

RE: Notice of Peaceful Demonstrations — November 6–7, 2026

From  Tseng, Steve <Steve.Tseng@vancouver.ca>

To  scottgilbertvan

Date in the email  Thu, 5 Nov 2026 17:37:06 +0000

Hello Scott. Thank you for providing advance notice of your planned demonstration and outlining your intentions. We respect your right to peaceful demonstration and ask that you observe the following: * Access: Keep all building entrances, sidewalks, vehicle routes and emergency access clear at all times. * Conduct: Do not interfere with staff, visitors or City operations. Treat everyone on site respectfully. * Security Directions: Follow directions from City Protective Services staff regarding site safety, access and security. * Noise: Be mindful of noise levels and the potential disruption to City staff and neighbouring businesses. * Parking: City Hall parking remains subject to standard fees, posted restrictions, availability, and enforcement. City Protective Services can assist with questions related to site safety and access (security.cov@vancouver.ca). However, address concerns about towing charges through 3-1-1 ([phone number omitted]). Questions concerning VPD must be directed to them. Thank you for your cooperation in maintaining a safe and accessible environment for everyone. Regards, Steve Tseng | Security Programs Manager CITY OF VANCOUVER | City Protective Services 453 W 12th Avenue | Vancouver, BC V5Y 1V4 steve.tseng@vancouver.ca<mailto:steve.tseng@vancouver.ca> Report incidents through the COV Currents, Security E-Reporting Web Page [core.resolver.com]<[email-security redirect omitted]> The City of Vancouver acknowledges that it is situated on the unceded traditional territories of the xʷməθkʷəy̓əm (Musqueam), Sḵwx̱wú7mesh (Squamish), and səlilwətaɬ (Tsleil-Waututh) Nations.

Link to this email

Sent · 10:30 am Vancouver time

FIPPA request — Busters/All Tech City payments, towing volumes, site rent and audit records (2021–2026)

From  Scott Gilbert

To  foi@vancouver.ca

Cc  Justin Schrump <justin.schrump@busterstowing.com>

Date in the email  Thu, 5 Nov 2026 09:30:23 -0800

To: City of Vancouver Access to Information & Privacy Office FORMAL GENERAL-INFORMATION REQUEST UNDER BC FIPPA Applicant: Scott Gilbert Response email: [email address omitted] Mailing address: 105 E Hastings St, Vancouver, BC V6A 1N5 Subject: City financial and operational records for All Tech Transport Ltd. dba Busters Towing — actual City payments, tow counts, municipal fleet costs, site rents and audit controls. Please open this as a *distinct, targeted general-information access request* and assign a file number. It complements my existing personal/contract oversight FOI matters, including file 2026-655 and my October 18, 2026 request for historical tow-level classification data. To limit duplication, I am NOT requesting another copy of the entire towing contract or individual private motorists' full impound records. I request copies or native electronic exports of the following EXISTING records held by or under the control of the City, including Accounts Payable, Engineering/Fleet Services, Parking Operations & Enforcement, City real estate/property, procurement/contract administration and any other City departments with responsive records. **Priority A — reconcile reported City towing costs and payments (January 1, 2021–December 31, 2025; 2026 to October 31 if readily retrievable).** 1. Existing payment-ledger/AP exports and invoices, purchase orders or invoice registers for payments to All Tech Transport Ltd. dba Busters Towing, Busters Towing (1987) Ltd. and any other named Busters contracting/payee entity: payment and service dates, supplier ID, invoice/PO number, amount (tax/extra charges separately where held), paying cost centre/department, GL/service account, description and contract ID. Please preserve transaction keys and provide CSV/XLSX if available. No bank-account details are requested. 2. The underlying existing reports, worksheets or calculations supporting the City Council report RTS 16536 (Nov. 13, 2024) showing towing expenditure of $1,111,659 (2021), $1,377,388 (2022), and $1,477,809 (2023), including which vendors, departments and service types are included, and any reconciliations to payments actually made. Include 2024 and 2025 annual totals if held. 3. Existing departmental fleet-tow logs, work orders, annual summaries or contractor management reports showing numbers and costs of City/Police/Parks/Fire/Engineering vehicles or equipment towed, by calendar year, department, reason (mechanical breakdown, collision, planned relocation, special recovery or other), vehicle class and cost. If a structured dispatch export already exists, provide it with private identifiers severed as needed. Include existing municipal/Police fleet asset or road-registered vehicle counts used for service planning. 4. Existing City insurance/ICBC claim-recovery ledgers or summary reports that record reimbursements, deductibles or recoveries of City-paid towing costs, including relevant claim/job/payment references to permit reconciliation without disclosing personal information. **Priority B — rent, licence payments and contract economics (January 1, 2013–December 31, 2025; 2026 year-to-date if readily retrievable).** 5. Annual rent/licence billing and receipts ledgers for City property used by Busters/All Tech, separately for 425 and 455 Industrial Avenue and other contracted sites (including 1150 East Kent Avenue South where applicable). Include any abatements, arrears, adjustments, credits, and amounts paid by the City for site improvements or relocation. Please include executed lease/licence amendments and existing market-rent appraisals, rent-review reports and property valuation comparables that have not already been disclosed. 6. Existing annual contract budgets, operating statements, vendor spend reports and reconciliations that compare money paid by the City to Busters against money received from Busters, including supporting calculations for the 2019 projected $6.615 million City spending and $5.082 million property revenue over seven years. **Priority C — payments for owner-funded impounds and oversight (January 1, 2021–October 31, 2026).** 7. Existing annual/monthly aggregate reports of bylaw tow requests, completed impounds, drop charges, parking/engineering relocations, City-paid charges and owner-paid towing/storage receipts, showing any amount collected *on behalf of the City*. Existing reconciliations, internal audits, sampling protocols or exception reports intended to prevent billing both the City and the vehicle owner or insurer for an unauthorized duplicate service. I seek aggregated summaries rather than names or identifiable owner invoices (which are covered by my prior request). 8. Existing records approving, interpreting or disputing the application of fuel surcharges to “load/secure,” standby, storage, winching, or other ancillary fees on **City-street bylaw impound** invoices, and rate-change implementation instructions, invoice-code definitions, sample audits and relevant compliance findings. Please distinguish public-bylaw customer tariffs from Schedule B City-paid services and the attached ICBC rate schedule. 9. The existing contract administration/City-held reporting records addressing the supplier's obligation to furnish next-business-day Excel bylaw impound reports (2020 agreement s.5.2(c)), service records for inspection (s.4.1(n)), management reports (s.7), and audits/accounts (s.8.5); include any records of City requests to Busters for records, responses or refusals, records-retention schedules and decisions declaring records outside the City's custody or control. Reference documents: 2020 executed agreement: https://vancouver.ca/files/cov/2021-324-release.pdf 2024 City report: https://council.vancouver.ca/20241113/documents/cfsc4.pdf 2019 contract award: https://council.vancouver.ca/20191002/documents/cfsc4.pdf I request existing records, not answers drafted for this FOI or creation of new analytical spreadsheets. Electronic records and CSV/XLSX are preferred. I do not seek individual motorists' names, phone numbers or personal addresses; redact personal data rather than withholding otherwise responsive aggregate or financial records. Please first produce or identify readily available material for Priority A. If the full request would attract significant search or preparation fees, provide a record inventory and estimated fees by category and allow me to narrow or phase the remaining priorities before work is incurred. If responsive information is held by a different City department or the Police Board, please identify the custodian and transfer or advise as appropriate. Where records are held by the contractor, please consider the City's existing contractual rights of access and specify any custody/control determination and its basis. Please acknowledge receipt, assign a case number, advise whether the $10 general-request application fee is due and how to pay it, and confirm that the search includes actual accounts payable and contract-administration systems. I have copied Justin Schrump of Busters Towing for transparency, as requested. This is a request to the City for records in the City's custody or control; no response from the copied contractor is a prerequisite to registering it. Sincerely, Scott Gilbert [phone number omitted] [email address omitted]

Link to this email

Sent · 10:29 am Vancouver time

Follow-up: Busters invoice surcharges, $1.48M City towing expenditure, and contract audit records

From  Scott Gilbert

To  David.Cheung2@vancouver.ca, Jim Dent <Jim.Dent@busterstowing.com>, Justin Schrump <justin.schrump@busterstowing.com>

Date in the email  Thu, 5 Nov 2026 09:29:31 -0800

Dear David, Jim and Justin, I am following up on the five towing invoices that Busters corrected from Category 3 to Category 2, resulting in a $719.23 refund on October 19. I appreciate that correction, but the remaining extra charges are disputed. The public records also raise broader questions about the City's payments, recordkeeping and audit controls. I ask for a substantive, itemized written response, not an assumption that any impropriety has already been established. **1. Specific fuel-surcharge and extra-service charges on my receipts.** The July 10, 2026 bill (total $557.16) contains a $34.39 fuel surcharge on the base tow and a separate $51.59 fuel surcharge associated with additional services; the September 14 invoice #3807932 ($303.08) contains $37.15 in fuel surcharge on the tow and a further $18.57 associated with $68.79 “Load/Secure Vehicle.” The July 27 invoice #3794199 likewise has $37.15 and $18.57 fuel entries. What *specific Impounding By-law section, operative tariff, contractual provision or authorized rate interpretation* permits fuel surcharges on each of those separately billed extras in a completed **public-street bylaw impound**? Please show the applicable percentage and calculation base as of each tow date, and distinguish a lawful surcharge applied once to multiple eligible components from any charge applied twice to the same service. The City's public fee webpage currently says 27% fuel surcharge is “applied to all fees” for public tows, whereas the 2020 contract's attached ICBC rate schedule addresses fuel surcharges on specified charges. Please explain precisely which schedule governs *customer invoices* and which governs *City-paid services*, and how the separate additional services themselves were authorized. A general statement that a surcharge applies to an authorized fee does not establish that the underlying extra fee was justified. The 2020 agreement's attached ICBC schedule describes “loading and securing” beyond 10 minutes in circumstances involving damage (such as a vehicle broken into pieces or requiring tarping). Identify the scene photographs, damage condition, actual added work, timing and tariff authority supporting “load/secure” and standby on my particular tows, rather than ordinary hook-up work already included in the base rate. Please provide a line-by-line recalculation and refund of any unsupported amounts (currently I estimate approximately $500 remains in dispute, subject to reconciliation). **2. City expenditure growth.** The City's November 13, 2024 report (RTS 16536, p. 5) reports towing costs of $1,111,659 in 2021, $1,377,388 in 2022 and $1,477,809 in 2023 — a 32.9% increase from 2021 to 2023. Please identify annual service volumes, rates, contractor payments and cost components behind that increase; distinguish vehicle breakdowns/collisions, special recoveries, planned equipment moves, civilian vehicle relocations, investigative tows and any standing/administrative fees. These are City-reported towing expenditures and should not automatically be equated with Busters-only revenue without a vendor reconciliation. **3. Test against a modest fleet breakdown model.** A preliminary *illustrative, not measured* model using the City's published 2022 fleet/equipment asset counts (Engineering 740, Parks 300, Police 440, Fire 128; 1,608 assets total), assumed annual breakdown/accident tow frequencies of 8%, 5%, 12% and 8%, respectively, and assumed average charges of $400, $250, $250 and $650, yields approximately 137 routine tows and $47,100 per year. The assumptions may be wrong, some assets are not road vehicles, and the City's broader towing costs may cover many additional functions. That is precisely why actual tow counts, fee categories, average charges and explanations of the approximately $1.43 million difference from the 2023 reported total are required. What were the actual vehicle and equipment counts and City-paid tows, by department and reason, in 2021–2025? **4. Owner charges versus City invoices.** The January 2004 Council report describes approximately $400,000 in City departmental towing expenses (including Parking Enforcement), yet separately says vehicle owners paid their own impoundments at no cost to the City. The February 2020 contract similarly requires collection of bylaw tow fees from owners and reports to the City, while authorizing City payment for specified other services. Please reconcile these categories and identify whether there are any charges payable by both the City and owners for a single dispatch, and what controls prevent unreconciled duplicate collection. Please distinguish towing fees, storage charges collected *on behalf of the City*, drop charges, and City-paid fleet/police/relocation work. **5. Contractor records and City responsibility.** David's October 7 response referred me to Busters as best positioned to verify VIN, weight classification, photographs and billing. Yet the released 2020 agreement requires a next-business-day Excel record of every bylaw impound (section 5.2(c)), contractor records available for inspection (section 4.1(n), within 48 hours of request), management reports (section 7), and City access to service accounts and audits (section 8.5). Please identify the responsible contract administrator, what records the City has already obtained, and why it could not independently review the disputed class/charge data. If any record is unavailable, identify the record type, contractual retention rule, custodian, search performed, and any corrective action. **6. City payments and property licence fees.** The 2019 award estimated City service expenditure of $6.615 million and City lease/licence revenue of $5.082 million over seven years. The 2020 contract section 5.2(l)(ii) sets beginning monthly site-licence fees of *at least* $40,000 for 425 Industrial Avenue and $20,500 for 455 Industrial Avenue ($726,000 annually combined, before adjustments). Please identify actual amounts billed/received for each property and actual City payments by fiscal year, including extensions, concessions, insurance recoveries and escalation terms. Were the lease terms independently appraised? **7. Oversight and next steps.** Please preserve relevant invoices, dispatch entries, original and adjusted fee codes, photos, rate versions, daily Excel reports, payment/credit records and audit trails. Please provide a written, item-by-item answer within ten business days, identify who is accountable for investigating systemic contract compliance (not just my own refund), and state whether an independent sample audit will be conducted. I am also sending a distinct targeted FOI request for *existing* municipal finance, fleet towing and property records; it is not a request to Busters to disclose private customer information. Sources for reference: City 2004 contract renewal: https://council.vancouver.ca/20040127/a3.pdf 2019 award: https://council.vancouver.ca/20191002/documents/cfsc4.pdf 2020 agreement (FOI 2021-324): https://vancouver.ca/files/cov/2021-324-release.pdf 2024 Council report: https://council.vancouver.ca/20241113/documents/cfsc4.pdf City fee page: https://vancouver.ca/streets-transportation/impounded-vehicles-and-towing-fees.aspx Sincerely, Scott Gilbert [phone number omitted] [email address omitted]

Link to this email

Reply or case update · 8:46 am Vancouver time

RE: Notice of Peaceful Demonstrations — November 6–7, 2026

From  VPD Protests Mailbox <Protests@vpd.ca>

To  Great Scott Gilbert <greatscottgilbert@gmail.com>

Cc  COOPER, Christopher <chris.cooper@vpd.ca>, YOUNG, Cesar <cesar.young@vpd.ca>, NILAUSEN, Thomas <TOM.NILAUSEN@vpd.ca>

Date in the email  Thu, 5 Nov 2026 15:46:36 +0000

Good morning, Mr. Gilbert, Given the information you have provided I do not foresee any issue with your planned protest. The fact that you have already stated that you will not be impeding business and/or traffic has already addressed the issues our office would have concerns with. If you have any further concerns or questions, please reach out to me. Kam Detective Constable 1941 Kam DHILLON Vancouver Police Department 3585 Graveley Street Vancouver, BC, V5K 5J5 Email: kam.dhillon@vpd.ca<mailto:kam.dhillon@vpd.ca> Phone: work [phone number omitted] cell [phone number omitted] Fax: [phone number omitted]
Earlier correspondence included in the email
From: Great Scott Gilbert <greatscottgilbert@gmail.com> Sent: Thursday, November 05, 2026 8:17 AM To: VPD Protests Mailbox <protests@vpd.ca> Cc: Jim.Dent@busterstowing.com; justin.schrump@busterstowing.com; David.Cheung2@vancouver.ca Subject: Notice of Peaceful Demonstrations — November 6–7, 2026 Message from an external sender Do not open attachments or click on links, unless you recognize the sender's email address and know the content is safe. Hello VPD Planning Assessment Team, I am providing advance notice of my intention to hold a peaceful demonstration outside Vancouver City Hall on Friday, November 6, 2026, potentially for the full day. The demonstration concerns disputed historical towing charges, vehicle classifications and contractor oversight involving Busters Towing and the City of Vancouver. I may hold additional peaceful demonstrations on public property outside Busters Towing beginning November 7. I intend to avoid obstructing entrances, sidewalks, vehicle traffic and emergency access. Please advise of any site-specific safety considerations, conflicting events or applicable requirements. I understand that peaceful assembly itself does not ordinarily require a protest permit. For context, five towing invoices were corrected in October 2026, resulting in a $719.23 refund. I continue to dispute charges on other historical invoices and request a documented investigation and refunds for verified overpayments. Please acknowledge receipt of this notice and identify a contact for any necessary coordination. Scott Gilbert [phone number omitted] [email address omitted]<mailto:[email address omitted]>

Link to this email

Sent · 8:16 am Vancouver time

Notice of Peaceful Demonstrations — November 6–7, 2026

From  Great Scott Gilbert <greatscottgilbert@gmail.com>

To  VPD Protests Mailbox <protests@vpd.ca>

Cc  Jim Dent <Jim.Dent@busterstowing.com>, Justin Schrump <justin.schrump@busterstowing.com>, David.Cheung2@vancouver.ca

Date in the email  Thu, 5 Nov 2026 07:16:42 -0800

Hello VPD Planning Assessment Team, I am providing advance notice of my intention to hold a peaceful demonstration outside Vancouver City Hall on Friday, November 6, 2026, potentially for the full day. The demonstration concerns disputed historical towing charges, vehicle classifications and contractor oversight involving Busters Towing and the City of Vancouver. I may hold additional peaceful demonstrations on public property outside Busters Towing beginning November 7. I intend to avoid obstructing entrances, sidewalks, vehicle traffic and emergency access. Please advise of any site-specific safety considerations, conflicting events or applicable requirements. I understand that peaceful assembly itself does not ordinarily require a protest permit. For context, five towing invoices were corrected in October 2026, resulting in a $719.23 refund. I continue to dispute charges on other historical invoices and request a documented investigation and refunds for verified overpayments. Please acknowledge receipt of this notice and identify a contact for any necessary coordination. Scott Gilbert [phone number omitted] [email address omitted]

Link to this email

Sent · 2:38 am Vancouver time

Fwd: Ref# 96357-2026 General Local Elections Disclosure Statement

From  Scott Gilbert

To  Vancouver Election <election@vancouver.ca>

Date in the email  Thu, 5 Nov 2026 01:38:15 -0800

Hello Vancouver Election Office, I was a candidate for Mayor in the October 17, 2026 Vancouver election. I am forwarding Elections BC's November 4 acceptance confirmation for my campaign financing disclosure, reference 96357. Elections BC confirms that the disclosure has been accepted and that no further action is currently required in relation to this report. I am requesting the return of my $100 nomination deposit following my on-time filing, under section 44.1(3)(b) of the Vancouver Charter. I will come by the Election Office today, November 5, 2026, to pick up the deposit. Please reply as soon as possible to confirm that it will be ready for collection, the pickup location and hours, and any identification or receipt I need to bring. Your website lists the Election Office at 305 West 8th Avenue, open 8:30 am to 5 pm. If it cannot be collected today, please confirm in writing when and how the City will return it, including whether it will be refunded to the original payment method, issued by cheque, or returned another way. Thank you, Scott Gilbert 2026 Vancouver mayoral candidate Elections BC reference: 96357
Read the attached forwarded email

Ref# 96357-2026 General Local Elections Disclosure Statement

EF <info@elections.bc.ca> · Wed, 4 Nov 2026 15:45:11 -0700

Hello Scott Gilbert: Re: 2026 General Local Elections Disclosure Statement This email confirms that Elections BC has accepted your disclosure statement for the 2026 General Local Elections. At this time, no further action is required in relation to this report. Our office may contact you if questions arise during our review, or if new information comes to our attention. As a reminder, if you become aware that the information in this report has changed, or that it was not complete or accurate, section 54 of Local Elections Campaign Financing Act requires an amended report to be filed with our office within 30 days. A copy of this financial report will be made publicly available on our website through our Financial Reports and Political Contributions System; however, you are responsible for ensuring all financial records and receipts supporting this report are retained for at least five years. If you have any questions, please contact Electoral Finance by phone at [phone number omitted] or by email at electoral.finance@elections.bc.ca. Sincerely, Electoral Finance Elections BC
Attachment filenames (1)
  • Ref# 96357-2026 General Local Elections Disclosure Statement.eml

Link to this email