From: Scott Gilbert <[email address omitted]>
Date: Thursday, November 5, 2026 at 10:30 AM
To: David.Cheung2@vancouver.ca <David.Cheung2@vancouver.ca>; Jim.Dent <Jim.Dent@busterstowing.com>; Justin Schrump <justin.schrump@busterstowing.com>
Subject: Follow-up: Busters invoice surcharges, $1.48M City towing expenditure, and contract audit records
Dear David, Jim and Justin,
I am following up on the five towing invoices that Busters corrected from Category 3 to Category 2, resulting in a $719.23 refund on October 19. I appreciate that correction, but the remaining extra charges are disputed. The public records also raise broader questions about the City’s payments, recordkeeping and audit controls. I ask for a substantive, itemized written response, not an assumption that any impropriety has already been established.
1. Specific fuel-surcharge and extra-service charges on my receipts. The July 10, 2026 bill (total $557.16) contains a $34.39 fuel surcharge on the base tow and a separate $51.59 fuel surcharge associated with additional services; the September 14 invoice #3807932 ($303.08) contains $37.15 in fuel surcharge on the tow and a further $18.57 associated with $68.79 “Load/Secure Vehicle.” The July 27 invoice #3794199 likewise has $37.15 and $18.57 fuel entries. What specific Impounding By-law section, operative tariff, contractual provision or authorized rate interpretation permits fuel surcharges on each of those separately billed extras in a completed public-street bylaw impound? Please show the applicable percentage and calculation base as of each tow date, and distinguish a lawful surcharge applied once to multiple eligible components from any charge applied twice to the same service.
The City’s public fee webpage currently says 27% fuel surcharge is “applied to all fees” for public tows, whereas the 2020 contract’s attached ICBC rate schedule addresses fuel surcharges on specified charges. Please explain precisely which schedule governs customer invoices and which governs City-paid services, and how the separate additional services themselves were authorized. A general statement that a surcharge applies to an authorized fee does not establish that the underlying extra fee was justified.
The 2020 agreement’s attached ICBC schedule describes “loading and securing” beyond 10 minutes in circumstances involving damage (such as a vehicle broken into pieces or requiring tarping). Identify the scene photographs, damage condition, actual added work, timing and tariff authority supporting “load/secure” and standby on my particular tows, rather than ordinary hook-up work already included in the base rate. Please provide a line-by-line recalculation and refund of any unsupported amounts (currently I estimate approximately $500 remains in dispute, subject to reconciliation).
2. City expenditure growth. The City’s November 13, 2024 report (RTS 16536, p. 5) reports towing costs of $1,111,659 in 2021, $1,377,388 in 2022 and $1,477,809 in 2023 — a 32.9% increase from 2021 to 2023. Please identify annual service volumes, rates, contractor payments and cost components behind that increase; distinguish vehicle breakdowns/collisions, special recoveries, planned equipment moves, civilian vehicle relocations, investigative tows and any standing/administrative fees. These are City-reported towing expenditures and should not automatically be equated with Busters-only revenue without a vendor reconciliation.
3. Test against a modest fleet breakdown model. A preliminary illustrative, not measured model using the City’s published 2022 fleet/equipment asset counts (Engineering 740, Parks 300, Police 440, Fire 128; 1,608 assets total), assumed annual breakdown/accident tow frequencies of 8%, 5%, 12% and 8%, respectively, and assumed average charges of $400, $250, $250 and $650, yields approximately 137 routine tows and $47,100 per year. The assumptions may be wrong, some assets are not road vehicles, and the City’s broader towing costs may cover many additional functions. That is precisely why actual tow counts, fee categories, average charges and explanations of the approximately $1.43 million difference from the 2023 reported total are required. What were the actual vehicle and equipment counts and City-paid tows, by department and reason, in 2021–2025?
4. Owner charges versus City invoices. The January 2004 Council report describes approximately $400,000 in City departmental towing expenses (including Parking Enforcement), yet separately says vehicle owners paid their own impoundments at no cost to the City. The February 2020 contract similarly requires collection of bylaw tow fees from owners and reports to the City, while authorizing City payment for specified other services. Please reconcile these categories and identify whether there are any charges payable by both the City and owners for a single dispatch, and what controls prevent unreconciled duplicate collection. Please distinguish towing fees, storage charges collected on behalf of the City, drop charges, and City-paid fleet/police/relocation work.
5. Contractor records and City responsibility. David’s October 7 response referred me to Busters as best positioned to verify VIN, weight classification, photographs and billing. Yet the released 2020 agreement requires a next-business-day Excel record of every bylaw impound (section 5.2©), contractor records available for inspection (section 4.1(n), within 48 hours of request), management reports (section 7), and City access to service accounts and audits (section 8.5). Please identify the responsible contract administrator, what records the City has already obtained, and why it could not independently review the disputed class/charge data. If any record is unavailable, identify the record type, contractual retention rule, custodian, search performed, and any corrective action.
6. City payments and property licence fees. The 2019 award estimated City service expenditure of $6.615 million and City lease/licence revenue of $5.082 million over seven years. The 2020 contract section 5.2(l)(ii) sets beginning monthly site-licence fees of at least $40,000 for 425 Industrial Avenue and $20,500 for 455 Industrial Avenue ($726,000 annually combined, before adjustments). Please identify actual amounts billed/received for each property and actual City payments by fiscal year, including extensions, concessions, insurance recoveries and escalation terms. Were the lease terms independently appraised?
7. Oversight and next steps. Please preserve relevant invoices, dispatch entries, original and adjusted fee codes, photos, rate versions, daily Excel reports, payment/credit records and audit trails. Please provide a written, item-by-item answer within ten business days, identify who is accountable for investigating systemic contract compliance (not just my own refund), and state whether an independent sample audit will be conducted. I am also sending a distinct targeted FOI request for existing municipal finance, fleet towing and property records; it is not a request to Busters to disclose private customer information.
Sources for reference:
City 2004 contract renewal:
https://council.vancouver.ca/20040127/a3.pdf
2019 award:
https://council.vancouver.ca/20191002/documents/cfsc4.pdf
2020 agreement (FOI 2021-324):
https://vancouver.ca/files/cov/2021-324-release.pdf
2024 Council report:
https://council.vancouver.ca/20241113/documents/cfsc4.pdf
City fee page:
https://vancouver.ca/streets-transportation/impounded-vehicles-and-towing-fees.aspx
Sincerely,
Scott Gilbert
[phone number omitted]
[email address omitted]<mailto:[email address omitted]>