Re: Audit request — Busters Towing vehicle-class billing and City contract oversight
From Scott Gilbert
To Office of the Auditor General <OAG@vancouver.ca>
Date in the email Thu, 29 Oct 2026 02:52:06 +0100
Dear Anna,
Thank you for your October 23 response. I ask the Office of the Auditor General to reconsider its decision not to proceed and to examine these concerns through the City’s planned review of Impounding By-law enforcement.
The explanation that a weight-dispute mechanism exists does not resolve the concern. It does not establish that the classifications were accurate, that the process was disclosed to affected people, that complaints were fairly reviewed, or that required records exist and are available for audit.
My 1976 GMC motorhome is under 20 feet, and the City billed it at the under-20-foot storage rate. Its manufacturer certification plate states a GVWR of 10,000 pounds, approximately 4,536 kg—well below the published Category 3 threshold of 6,301 kg. The City confirmed Category 3 billing on five tow dates. The same vehicle was repeatedly assigned the higher class across separate events. On the available evidence, that is not reasonably explained as a one-off mistake. The City should be required to show the VIN-specific weight basis and records supporting each charge.
I have not been able to identify any finished motorhome under 20 feet with a published rating in the Category 3 range. The compact motorhome examples I found are rated below that threshold. The combination of this vehicle’s short length, its 10,000-pound manufacturer rating, and five Category 3 charges is compelling evidence that the recorded classifications require independent scrutiny. If the City relies on a different GVW measure, it should be able to identify that measure, the weight value, and its source for each tow.
There is a second, earlier instance involving a 1991 Grumman-Olson vehicle under 20 feet that my girlfriend, Victoria Mansfield, used to own. We challenged its classification and showed the vehicle’s weight information, but no refund was issued. We were not told that a dispute mechanism existed. Instead, we were told that refunds would not be issued for any reason. That account conflicts with the process described to your office and raises a direct question about whether the mechanism was communicated and applied in practice. Please include this prior complaint in the review and examine the related records.
A meaningful review should compare the VIN recorded for each municipal tow with the recorded year, make, model, body configuration, and vehicle description; establish the weight value and source used to assign the charged class; and compare that evidence with the applicable fee category. It should also examine complaints, supporting evidence, corrections, refunds or refusals, and the contractor’s recordkeeping and reporting obligations under the City contract. Reviewing a sufficiently broad sample of municipal tows would show whether these were isolated events or part of a wider pattern.
I am also concerned that the City has denied holding records that it is entitled to receive under the contract. If records needed to verify VINs, vehicle descriptions, weight sources, class assignments, invoice histories, and complaint outcomes are missing or unavailable, that is a contract-oversight and internal-control issue in its own right. The audit should determine what records Busters was required to maintain and provide, what the City actually received, and how the City checked compliance.
The evidence raises a serious possibility of repeated, unsupported overbilling. I am not asking your Office to make a criminal finding. I am asking for an independent records-based examination capable of determining whether vehicles were knowingly or systematically assigned unsupported weight classes and whether the public was charged as a result. If the evidence supports suspected criminal conduct, it should be referred to police or another appropriate authority.
Please reconsider the decision not to proceed and confirm whether these matters can be examined as part of the planned Impounding By-law enforcement review. Please also provide or identify the written procedure, evidence requirements, eligibility rules, and review route for the weight-dispute mechanism your Office was told exists. I am pursuing the individual classification disputes separately.
Regards,
Scott Gilbert
[email address omitted]
[phone number omitted]
Earlier correspondence included in the email
On Fri, 23 Oct 2026 20:10:29 +0000, Office of the Auditor General <OAG@vancouver.ca> wrote:
> Dear Scott,
>
>
> Thank you for your correspondence of September 28, 2026 to the City of Vancouver’s Office of the Auditor General (OAG).
>
> Request for a Performance Audit
>
> We acknowledge receipt of your request that the Auditor General consider the towing and record-keeping practices of Buster’s Towing, a City contractor, as a topic for a future performance audit. We appreciate your suggestion and will raise the broader procurement and contracting issues with the Auditor General for consideration when he reviews the OAG’s Audit Plan later this year. However, for transparency, we did not find any immediate reason for concern when the impound yard staff outlined their processes to us; we discuss this further in the section below. It is therefore unlikely that a performance audit of that area would be a priority for our relatively small team.
>
>
> The Audit Plan is published on January 30 each year. We encourage you to visit the Auditor General’s webpage<https://vancouver.ca/your-government/auditor-general.aspx> on or after that date to see which audits are planned for 2027 through to the end of the Auditor General’s term in 2028. Do note that performance audits typically look at the overall economy, efficiency and effectiveness of government operations rather than specific incidents. While your experience may be considered within that broader context, an audit would not investigate or report specifically on the incidents you mentioned.
>
>
> I also note that our Office has plans to review the City's approach to enforcement of its Impoundment By-law, so we may be able to consider the issues you raise as part of that work.
>
> Request for Review Under the City of Vancouver Whistleblower Policy
>
> As you noted, consideration of your complaint under the Whistleblower Policy (COUN-010) is another potential option. For this purpose, I confidentially forwarded your report to the OAG Whistleblower Team for an initial assessment. This is the first step in the process for determining whether the concerns you raise could, on their face, rise to the high bar of “serious wrongdoing” necessary to proceed with a preliminary assessment.
>
>
> Last Wednesday, the team called the City Impound Yard to inquire about its process for estimating gross vehicle weight for the purpose of determining towing fees. The team was informed that this estimate is based on the Vehicle Identification Number (VIN) and publicly available information about the weight of that particular vehicle. However, we learned that the impound yard has a formal mechanism in place for vehicle owners to dispute this estimated weight, and that refunds are provided for a portion of the fee when sufficient evidence of a discrepancy is provided.
>
>
> Given the existence of this dispute mechanism, and that the Whistleblower Policy is not intended to duplicate the functions of other City departments, we will not be proceeding further under the Whistleblower Policy. We suggest that you contact the City Impound Yard at [phone number omitted] to inquire about the process for disputing the weights recorded on the invoices you received. If, after proceeding through that process, you still believe there is a governance issue that could amount to “serious wrongdoing,” we could reconsider the issue, but there would need to be compelling evidence of that.
>
>
> Thank you again for your engagement with the Office of the Auditor General for the City of Vancouver.
>
> Best regards,
>
> Anna
>
> On behalf of the Office of the Auditor General
>
>
>
> This email contains information that is CONFIDENTIAL. Any use of this communication by an unintended recipient is strictly prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient, please notify us and destroy this email.
>
> ________________________________
> From: Scott Gilbert <[email address omitted]>
> Sent: 28 September 2026 20:18
> To: Office of the Auditor General <OAG@vancouver.ca>
> Subject: Audit request — Busters Towing vehicle-class billing and City contract oversight
>
> Dear Office of the Auditor General, I am requesting that the Office consider an independent performance and compliance audit of the City of Vancouver’s administration and oversight of the municipal towing contract with All Tech Transport Ltd. ,
>
>
> Dear Office of the Auditor General,
>
> I am requesting that the Office consider an independent performance and compliance audit of the City of Vancouver’s administration and oversight of the municipal towing contract with All Tech Transport Ltd., doing business as Busters Towing.
>
> My immediate concern is repeated use of a higher vehicle-weight classification when Busters tows my 1976 GMC Vandura motorhome, BC plate [plate omitted]. The manufacturer certification plate states a GVWR of 10,000 lb, or approximately 4,536 kg. However, Busters invoice 3807932 for the September 14, 2026 tow records the vehicle as “Group 3,” defined on the invoice as over 6,300 kg to 9,072 kg. I paid $303.08 on that invoice. A July 27 receipt also records Group 3.
>
> In my experience, the same higher classification has been used every single time this motorhome has been towed recently, across different tow drivers and incidents, including tows on or about July 10, July 20, July 27, September 14 and September 22. The documents currently in my possession expressly show Group 3 on the July 27 and September 14 transactions; I am asking that the source invoices and system records be examined to confirm the classification used on every other tow.
>
> Because the same vehicle and licence plate have repeatedly passed through Busters’ dispatch, yard and billing systems, and because management has now received written notice of the dispute, this should not be treated solely as a possible one-off driver error. The recurrence across different operators raises a reasonable question whether the classification results from a billing-system default, a company instruction, training, inadequate controls, or a practice known to management.
>
> I am not asking the Office to presume fraud or criminal wrongdoing. I am asking for a records-based audit capable of determining whether the public has been charged in accordance with the City contract and applicable bylaw rates.
>
> I ask that the proposed audit include:
>
> 1. Reconciliation of every Busters tow involving plate [plate omitted], including the weight/class recorded, the source used for that classification, the driver and dispatcher identifiers, the applicable tariff, and a line-by-line recalculation of the invoice.
> 2. Review of additional “load/secure,” release/unhook, equipment, standby, fuel-surcharge, storage and second-truck charges to determine whether any fee was unsupported, duplicated or calculated using the wrong vehicle class.
> 3. A statistically meaningful sample of other Busters municipal tows, particularly motorhomes, vans and vehicles assigned to Groups 2 and 3, including transactions that never generated a complaint.
> 4. Analysis of complaints, corrected invoices, refunds, chargebacks, damage claims and repeated classification issues by driver, dispatcher and billing code.
> 5. Assessment of whether City contract administrators actually review Busters’ dispatch, GPS, vehicle-weight, tow-method, invoice and daily-report data, and whether documented breaches have resulted in corrective action.
> 6. Public reporting of aggregate findings, together with reimbursement of confirmed overcharges and controls preventing recurrence.
>
> Please also ensure that relevant dispatch logs, invoice histories and edits, rate tables, vehicle-class fields, photographs, GPS data, communications, complaint records, refund records and contract-management records are preserved. City FOI file 2026-655 concerns related towing records and may assist in locating the relevant material.
>
> Please acknowledge this request, advise whether it will be considered during audit planning or referred for preliminary assessment, and identify any additional records the Office requires from me.
>
> Regards,
>
> Scott Gilbert
> [email address omitted]<mailto:[email address omitted]>
> [phone number omitted]